Skip to content

Principles and Methods of Taxonomy

Species concepts, codes of nomenclature, types, classification systems, numerical taxonomy, cladistics, molecular phylogenetics and DNA barcoding for CSIR NET.

  • 20 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Plant With Two Names
  3. Taxonomy, Systematics and Classification
  4. Species Concepts
  5. Nomenclature
  6. Classification Systems
  7. Methods: Classical and Quantitative Taxonomy
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Plant With Two Names

How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: species concepts and their limits, rules of the botanical and zoological codes, type terminology, rank endings, classification systems, phenetics versus cladistics, mono-, para- and polyphyly, barcode genes. Part C: compute similarity coefficients, build a UPGMA tree, find the most parsimonious tree from a character matrix, count possible trees, correct a distance for multiple hits, and judge nomenclatural statements.


Taxonomy, Systematics and Classification

TermMeaning
TaxonomyTheory and practice of identifying, describing, naming and classifying organisms
SystematicsThe study of the diversity of organisms and the relationships among them (G. G. Simpson’s definition); includes taxonomy plus phylogeny
ClassificationArranging organisms into groups (taxa) in a hierarchy of ranks
IdentificationAssigning a specimen to an already known taxon (with keys, floras, comparison with herbarium or museum specimens, DNA)
NomenclatureApplying correct names according to the codes
Taxon (plural taxa)A named group at any rank (Mangifera, Anacardiaceae)
Category / rankThe level in the hierarchy (genus, family)

Stages of taxonomy:

  • Alpha taxonomy: finding, describing and naming species.
  • Beta taxonomy: arranging species into a natural system of higher categories.
  • Gamma taxonomy: intraspecific variation and evolutionary studies (biosystematics).

Principal ranks (from top): Domain → Kingdom → Phylum (botany also uses Division) → Class → Order → Family → Genus → Species. Intermediate ranks (subfamily, tribe, subgenus, section, series) are added as needed.

Taxonomic aids: herbaria (pressed, dried, labelled specimens on sheets), botanical gardens, museums (preserved and skeletal specimens), zoological parks, keys, floras, faunas, monographs (a complete account of one taxon), revisions, manuals and catalogues.

Keys use pairs of contrasting statements (couplets) in which each choice is a lead:

  • Indented (yoked) key: the alternatives of each couplet are indented under one another; easy to see relationships but uses horizontal space.
  • Bracketed (parallel) key: the two leads of each couplet are printed together and numbered; compact.
  • Multi-access (polyclave) keys: characters can be used in any order; computer-based interactive keys.

Species Concepts

No single concept works for all organisms; CSIR NET asks for the defining criterion and the main weakness of each.

ConceptDefining criterionProposed or associated withMain limitation
Typological (morphological)Individuals conform to a type; species differ by fixed morphological gapsLinnaean traditionIgnores variation, sexual dimorphism, life stages and cryptic species
NominalisticOnly individuals exist; species are mental constructsSome 18th-century naturalistsSpecies do behave as real units in nature
Biological (BSC)Groups of actually or potentially interbreeding natural populations reproductively isolated from other such groupsErnst Mayr (1942)Cannot apply to asexual organisms, fossils, or allopatric populations whose crossing cannot be tested; plants often hybridise
EvolutionaryA single lineage of ancestor–descendant populations with its own evolutionary tendencies and historical fateG. G. Simpson; E. O. WileyHard to apply in practice
PhylogeneticThe smallest diagnosable cluster of individuals with a pattern of ancestry and descent (or a minimal monophyletic group)Joel Cracraft and othersTends to split species finely (“taxonomic inflation”)
EcologicalA lineage occupying a distinct adaptive zone (niche)Leigh Van ValenDifferent species can share niches; one species can use several
RecognitionShared specific mate-recognition systemHugh PatersonFocus on fertilisation systems; little help for asexuals
CohesionThe most inclusive population held together by genetic and demographic exchangeabilityAlan TempletonAbstract

Prokaryotes do not fit the BSC (asexual, horizontal gene transfer). Bacterial species are defined polyphasically: phenotype plus genotype. Commonly used thresholds are DNA–DNA hybridisation of about 70% or more, and the genome-based average nucleotide identity (ANI) of about 95–96%; 16S rRNA identity below about 98.7% usually indicates different species (higher identity does not prove the same species).

Special cases: sibling (cryptic) species are morphologically almost identical but reproductively isolated (members of the Anopheles gambiae complex; Drosophila pseudoobscura and D. persimilis). Polytypic species have several subspecies; monotypic species have none. Sympatric species share an area; allopatric species occupy separate areas.


Nomenclature

Binomial nomenclature and the codes

Carl Linnaeus established consistent binomial names: a generic name (capitalised) plus a specific epithet (lower case), both italicised or underlined when hand-written (Homo sapiens). The name may be followed by the author’s name (Mangifera indica L., where “L.” stands for Linnaeus).

CodeCoversStarting point for priority
ICN: International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi and plants (formerly ICBN; renamed at the 2011 Melbourne Congress)Plants, algae, fungi (including oomycetes and slime moulds traditionally treated as fungi)Linnaeus, Species Plantarum, 1 May 1753 (for most groups)
ICZN: International Code of Zoological NomenclatureAnimalsLinnaeus, Systema Naturae, 10th edition, 1758
ICNP: International Code of Nomenclature of ProkaryotesBacteria and ArchaeaApproved Lists of Bacterial Names, 1 January 1980
ICVCN: International Code of Virus Classification and Nomenclature (ICTV)VirusesICTV has adopted a binomial format for virus species names (genus + epithet)
ICNCP: International Code of Nomenclature for Cultivated PlantsCultivars and groups—

The codes are independent of each other: the same generic name can be used for a plant and an animal (the genus Oenanthe is both a plant genus and a bird genus).

Principles common to the codes

  1. Names are Latin or latinised, regardless of their origin.
  2. Priority: the correct name is the earliest validly (botany: validly and effectively) published legitimate name, from the starting date. Long-used names can be conserved (nomina conservanda) against strict priority.
  3. Typification: every name is permanently attached to a type; the name follows the type, not the description.
  4. One correct name: each taxon with a given circumscription, position and rank has only one correct name. Later names for the same taxon are synonyms; the same name for different taxa is a homonym (later homonyms are illegitimate).
  5. Rules are retroactive unless stated otherwise.

Botanical versus zoological rules

PointBotany (ICN)Zoology (ICZN)
Tautonyms (generic name repeated as epithet)Not allowed (Linaria linaria is invalid)Allowed (Naja naja, Rattus rattus, Gorilla gorilla)
Ranks below speciesSubspecies, variety, form (forma) are regulatedOnly subspecies is regulated (trinomial: Gorilla gorilla gorilla)
Description for valid publicationDiagnosis in Latin or English for new names published from 2012Any language; must state characters that differentiate the taxon
Author citation after transfer to another genusOriginal author in parentheses, followed by the author of the new combination: Cajanus cajan (L.) Millsp. (first named Cytisus cajan L.)Original author (and year) in parentheses, without the name of the person who made the transfer: Passer domesticus (Linnaeus, 1758), first named Fringilla domestica
Synonym terminologyEarlier name has prioritySenior synonym (earlier) versus junior synonym (later)
FungiSince 2013, one fungus, one name (separate names for sexual and asexual stages abolished)—

Rank endings (botany and zoology)

RankPlantsAlgaeFungiAnimals
Division / phylum-phyta-phyta-mycota(not regulated)
Class-opsida-phyceae-mycetes(not regulated)
Order-ales-ales-ales(not regulated)
Superfamily———-oidea
Family-aceae-aceae-aceae-idae
Subfamily-oideae-oideae-oideae-inae
Tribe-eae-eae-eae-ini

Eight conserved alternative family names (allowed in botany alongside the -aceae form): Compositae (Asteraceae), Cruciferae (Brassicaceae), Gramineae (Poaceae), Guttiferae (Clusiaceae), Labiatae (Lamiaceae), Leguminosae (Fabaceae), Palmae (Arecaceae), Umbelliferae (Apiaceae).

Type specimens

TypeDefinition
HolotypeThe one specimen designated by the author as the name-bearing type in the original publication
IsotypeA duplicate of the holotype (part of the same collection, same collector, same number) (botany)
SyntypeAny of two or more specimens cited in the original description when no holotype was designated
LectotypeA specimen selected later from the original material to serve as the type when no holotype was designated or it is lost
NeotypeA specimen selected as type when all original material is missing
ParatypeA specimen cited in the original description other than the holotype (and its duplicates)
EpitypeA specimen chosen to interpret an ambiguous holotype, lectotype or neotype (botany)
Topotype (informal)A specimen from the type locality
Allotype (informal, zoology)A specimen of the opposite sex to the holotype

Classification Systems

TypeBasisExamples
ArtificialOne or a few convenient charactersLinnaeus’s sexual system (number and arrangement of stamens)
NaturalOverall similarity using many charactersBentham and Hooker, Genera Plantarum (1862–1883): seed plants as dicots (Polypetalae, Gamopetalae, Monochlamydeae), gymnosperms, monocots; still used to arrange several Indian herbaria
Phylogenetic (pre-molecular)Presumed evolutionary relationshipsEngler and Prantl; John Hutchinson; Armen Takhtajan; Arthur Cronquist
Molecular phylogeneticDNA sequence data and cladistic methodsAngiosperm Phylogeny Group (APG I 1998, II 2003, III 2009, APG IV 2016)

Kingdom systems: Linnaeus’s two kingdoms (plants, animals); Ernst Haeckel added Protista; Herbert Copeland four kingdoms (Monera separate); R. H. Whittaker’s five kingdoms (1969): Monera, Protista, Fungi, Plantae, Animalia, separated by cell type, organisation and nutrition; Carl Woese’s three domains (1990) on rRNA sequences. Later schemes (Thomas Cavalier-Smith and others) split the protists into several kingdoms or supergroups because “Protista” is paraphyletic.


Methods: Classical and Quantitative Taxonomy

Classical taxonomy

Uses morphology (above all floral and reproductive characters in plants), with anatomy, embryology, palynology (pollen), cytology (chromosome number and karyotype: cytotaxonomy), chemistry (secondary metabolites, proteins: chemotaxonomy; immunological similarity: serotaxonomy) and ecology as supporting evidence. Characters are weighted by the taxonomist’s judgement.

Three schools of quantitative and phylogenetic classification

SchoolGroups byKey figuresOutput
Phenetics (numerical taxonomy)Overall similarity, many characters weighted equally (Adansonian principle)Robert Sokal and Peter Sneath (Principles of Numerical Taxonomy, 1963)Phenogram (dendrogram)
Cladistics (phylogenetic systematics)Shared derived characters (synapomorphies) only; only monophyletic groups acceptedWilli HennigCladogram
Evolutionary systematicsBoth branching and degree of divergence; paraphyletic groups allowed if distinctMayr, SimpsonClassical classifications (for example class Reptilia separate from Aves)

Numerical taxonomy step by step

  1. Choose the units: Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs), the terminal units being classified.
  2. Record many characters (numerical taxonomists recommend a large number, often quoted as several dozen) and code them (binary 1/0 or multistate).
  3. Compute a similarity (or distance) coefficient for every pair of OTUs.
  4. Cluster the similarity matrix (UPGMA, single linkage, complete linkage).
  5. Draw a phenogram and, if wanted, check its fit to the matrix (cophenetic correlation).

Similarity coefficients for binary characters. For two OTUs, count: a = characters present in both (1,1); b and c = present in only one (1,0 and 0,1); d = absent in both (0,0).

$$S_{SM} = \frac{a + d}{a + b + c + d} \qquad\qquad S_J = \frac{a}{a + b + c}$$

The simple matching coefficient counts shared absences as similarity; Jaccard’s coefficient ignores them (sensible when absence of a character in two taxa may have different causes).

UPGMA (Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic mean): join the two closest clusters; the distance from the new cluster to any other is the average of all pairwise distances between their members; repeat. The node height is half the joining distance. UPGMA assumes a constant rate (molecular clock), so it gives a rooted, ultrametric tree; neighbour-joining (NJ) does not assume a clock.

Cladistics: vocabulary Part B depends on

TermMeaningExample
PlesiomorphyAncestral character stateFive digits in tetrapods
ApomorphyDerived character stateFeathers
SynapomorphyShared derived state; the only evidence for a cladeFeathers for birds; hair for mammals
SymplesiomorphyShared ancestral state; does not indicate a cladeScales in “reptiles”
AutapomorphyDerived state unique to one terminal taxonBipedal gait unique to hominins among apes
HomoplasySimilarity not due to common ancestry: convergence, parallelism or reversalWings of bats and birds
OutgroupA taxon outside the study group, used to decide character polarity and to root the tree—

Kinds of groups:

GroupContainsExample
Monophyletic (clade)An ancestor and all its descendantsMammals; birds; land plants (embryophytes)
ParaphyleticAn ancestor and some of its descendantsReptilia excluding birds; “Pisces” (fishes excluding tetrapods); dicots; Protista; prokaryotes; “invertebrates”; “pteridophytes” (lycophytes + ferns, leaving out seed plants)
PolyphyleticDescendants of different ancestors, ancestor excluded; grouped by convergence“Warm-blooded animals” (birds + mammals); “algae”

Building trees from characters:

  • Maximum parsimony: choose the tree requiring the fewest evolutionary changes. Uninformative characters (autapomorphies, or states shared by all) do not discriminate between trees. A character is parsimony-informative only if at least two states each occur in at least two taxa.
  • Consistency index CI = (minimum possible number of changes) / (observed number of changes on the tree); 1 means no homoplasy.
  • Distance methods: UPGMA, neighbour-joining.
  • Maximum likelihood and Bayesian inference: use an explicit model of sequence evolution.
  • Support: bootstrap values (resampling characters with replacement); Bayesian posterior probabilities.

How many trees? For n taxa:

$$\text{unrooted bifurcating trees} = (2n-5)!! \qquad \text{rooted} = (2n-3)!!$$

(k!! is the product of odd numbers down to 1.) For 4 taxa: 3 unrooted, 15 rooted. For 5 taxa: 15 unrooted, 105 rooted. For 10 taxa: over 34 million rooted trees, which is why heuristic searches are used.

Correcting for multiple hits. The observed proportion of differing sites, p, underestimates the true number of substitutions because a site can change more than once. The Jukes–Cantor correction:

$$d = -\frac{3}{4}\ln\left(1 - \frac{4}{3}p\right)$$

The correction is small for small p and grows as p approaches the saturation value of 0.75.

Gene trees and species trees can disagree because of incomplete lineage sorting, horizontal gene transfer (common in prokaryotes) and hybridisation, and because paralogous genes may be compared by mistake.

Molecular taxonomy and DNA barcoding

DNA barcoding identifies species from a short standard gene region (proposed by Paul Hebert and colleagues in 2003).

GroupStandard barcode region
AnimalsMitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI), about 650 bp near the 5’ end
Land plantsPlastid rbcL + matK (often supplemented with trnH–psbA and nuclear ITS)
FungiNuclear ribosomal ITS (internal transcribed spacer)
Bacteria and Archaea16S rRNA gene

Other molecular markers in systematics: RFLP, RAPD, AFLP, microsatellites (SSRs) for population-level work; whole genomes for deep phylogeny (phylogenomics).

graph TD
    Q["Two organisms look alike.
Same group?"] --> A{"Is the shared
character derived?"} A -- "No, ancestral" --> S["Symplesiomorphy:
no evidence of a clade"] A -- "Yes" --> B{"Inherited from a
common ancestor?"} B -- "Yes" --> C["Synapomorphy:
supports a clade"] B -- "No, evolved separately" --> H["Homoplasy:
convergence or reversal"]

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Taxonomy: naming and classifyingvsSystematics: diversity and relationships (includes phylogeny)
Phenogram: overall similarityvsCladogram: shared derived characters
Synapomorphy: shared derived; defines cladesvsSymplesiomorphy: shared ancestral; misleading
Paraphyletic: excludes some descendants (reptiles without birds)vsPolyphyletic: unites convergent taxa (warm-blooded animals)
Holotype: designated by the authorvsLectotype: chosen later from original material
Isotype: duplicate of holotypevsParatype: other specimens cited in the protologue
Simple matching: counts shared absencesvsJaccard: ignores shared absences
UPGMA: assumes clock, rootedvsNeighbour-joining: no clock, unrooted
Tautonym: allowed in zoologyvsNot allowed in botany

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which code permits tautonyms?
  2. What is a specimen selected as type from the original material when no holotype was designated called?
  3. Which gene region is the standard DNA barcode for animals?
Answers
  1. ICZN (zoological code), for example Naja naja.
  2. Lectotype.
  3. Mitochondrial COI (cytochrome c oxidase subunit I).

Level 2: Part B Style

Q1 (practice). Two OTUs were scored for 30 binary characters: 12 characters present in both, 4 present only in the first, 4 present only in the second, and 10 absent in both. The simple matching and Jaccard coefficients are:

  • (a) 0.60 and 0.73
  • (b) 0.73 and 0.60
  • (c) 0.40 and 0.60
  • (d) 0.73 and 0.40
Answer and explanation

(b). \(S_{SM} = (12 + 10)/30 = 0.733\). \(S_J = 12/(12 + 4 + 4) = 0.60\). Jaccard is lower because it ignores the 10 shared absences.

Q2 (practice). How many distinct rooted bifurcating trees are possible for five taxa?

  • (a) 15
  • (b) 24
  • (c) 105
  • (d) 945
Answer and explanation

(c). Rooted trees = (2n − 3)!! = 7!! = 7 × 5 × 3 × 1 = 105. 15 is the number of unrooted trees for five taxa; 945 is rooted trees for six.

Q3 (practice). Which of the following is a paraphyletic group?

  • (a) Mammalia
  • (b) Embryophyta (land plants)
  • (c) Traditional “Pisces” (all fishes, excluding tetrapods)
  • (d) Aves
Answer and explanation

(c). Tetrapods descend from lobe-finned fishes, so a group of all fishes that leaves out tetrapods excludes some descendants of its common ancestor. The others are clades.

Q4 (practice). In botanical nomenclature, which ending indicates the rank of order?

  • (a) -aceae
  • (b) -oideae
  • (c) -ales
  • (d) -idae
Answer and explanation

(c). -aceae is family, -oideae subfamily; -idae is an animal family ending (and in plants a subclass ending).

Level 3: Part C Style

Q1 (practice). The distance matrix below gives pairwise distances between four taxa. Build a UPGMA tree and give the height of each node.

ABCD
A—4812
B—1014
C—10
D—
Answer and worked solution
  1. Smallest distance AB = 4 → join A and B; node height 4/2 = 2.
  2. New distances: d(AB, C) = (8 + 10)/2 = 9; d(AB, D) = (12 + 14)/2 = 13; d(C, D) = 10. Smallest is 9 → join (AB) with C; node height 9/2 = 4.5.
  3. d(ABC, D) = (AD + BD + CD)/3 = (12 + 14 + 10)/3 = 12 → join with D; root height 12/2 = 6.

Tree: (((A, B), C), D), rooted, with D the most divergent taxon. Notice that C is as far from D (10) as from B (10); it joins A and B only because UPGMA averages its distances to A and B (8 and 10). If rates differ among lineages, this averaging can give the wrong topology, and neighbour-joining is safer.

Q2 (practice). Four taxa were scored for five binary characters (0 = ancestral state).

Taxon12345
W00010
X00100
Y11000
Z11101

(i) Which characters are parsimony-informative? (ii) Give the length of each of the three unrooted trees and identify the most parsimonious one. (iii) Calculate the consistency index of that tree and name the homoplastic character.

Answer and worked solution
  1. Informative characters need two states each shared by at least two taxa: 1, 2 and 3. Characters 4 (only W) and 5 (only Z) are autapomorphies and cost one step on every tree.

  2. Tree lengths (steps for characters 1–5):

    • WX | YZ: 1 + 1 + 2 + 1 + 1 = 6
    • WY | XZ: 2 + 2 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 7
    • WZ | XY: 2 + 2 + 2 + 1 + 1 = 8

    The most parsimonious tree is ((W, X), (Y, Z)), supported by the synapomorphies in characters 1 and 2.

  3. Minimum possible steps = 5 (one per binary character); observed = 6. CI = 5/6 = 0.83. Character 3 (shared by X and Z) is homoplastic on this tree: it changes twice (convergence or a gain and a reversal).

Q3 (practice). Two aligned DNA sequences of 500 sites differ at 150 sites. Which statements are correct?

(A) The uncorrected p-distance is 0.30. (B) The Jukes–Cantor distance is about 0.38 substitutions per site. (C) The corrected distance is larger than p because some sites have changed more than once. (D) If the substitution rate is 10⁻⁹ per site per year in each lineage, the sequences diverged about 150 million years ago using the uncorrected distance.

  • (a) A and B only
  • (b) A, B and C only
  • (c) A, B, C and D
  • (d) C and D only
Answer and worked solution

(c) A, B, C and D.

  • (A) p = 150/500 = 0.30.
  • (B) \(d = -\tfrac{3}{4}\ln(1 - 0.4) = -0.75 \times (-0.511) = 0.383\).
  • (C) Correct: multiple hits at a site are invisible in the raw count.
  • (D) T = p/(2r) = 0.30/(2 × 10⁻⁹) = 1.5 × 10⁸ years = 150 Myr. The statement is arithmetically correct; using the corrected distance would give about 192 Myr, which is the better estimate.

Quick Revision Table

ItemFact
Alpha / beta / gamma taxonomyDescribe and name / arrange in hierarchy / intraspecific and evolutionary
BSCMayr 1942; interbreeding, reproductively isolated; fails for asexuals, fossils
Phylogenetic speciesSmallest diagnosable monophyletic cluster
Prokaryote speciesDDH ≥ ~70%; ANI ~95–96%; 16S < ~98.7% → different species
CodesICN (algae, fungi, plants), ICZN, ICNP, ICVCN, ICNCP
Starting pointsPlants 1 May 1753 (Species Plantarum); animals 1758 (Systema Naturae 10th ed.); prokaryotes 1 Jan 1980
TautonymsZoology yes (Naja naja); botany no
Plant endings-phyta, -opsida, -ales, -aceae, -oideae, -eae
Animal endings-oidea, -idae, -inae, -ini
TypesHolotype, isotype, syntype, lectotype, neotype, paratype, epitype
SystemsLinnaeus sexual (artificial); Bentham & Hooker (natural); Engler & Prantl, Takhtajan, Cronquist; APG IV 2016
KingdomsWhittaker 5 (1969); Woese 3 domains (1990)
PheneticsSokal & Sneath 1963; OTUs; equal weighting; phenogram
CoefficientsSM = (a + d)/n; Jaccard = a/(a + b + c)
UPGMAAverage linkage; assumes clock; node height = half the distance
CladisticsHennig; synapomorphy defines clades; outgroup sets polarity
GroupsMono (all), para (some: reptiles, dicots, Protista), poly (convergent)
Tree countsUnrooted (2n − 5)!!; rooted (2n − 3)!!; 4 taxa: 3 and 15
CIMinimum steps / observed steps
Jukes–Cantord = −¾ ln(1 − 4p/3)
BarcodesCOI (animals), rbcL + matK (plants), ITS (fungi), 16S (prokaryotes)

Key Takeaways

What’s Next