Skip to content

Genetic Mapping: Linkage, Tetrads, Bacteria and Markers

Three-point crosses, interference, tetrad analysis, bacterial conjugation and transduction, molecular markers and plant mapping populations for CSIR NET.

  • 22 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Student’s Overnight Map
  3. Linkage Maps from Test Crosses
  4. Tetrad Analysis
  5. Mapping in Bacteria: Gene Transfer
  6. Molecular Markers
  7. Mapping Populations in Plants
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Student’s Overnight Map


Linkage Maps from Test Crosses

Two-point mapping

For a dihybrid in a test cross:

$$\text{RF} = \frac{\text{number of recombinant progeny}}{\text{total progeny}} \times 100 \;=\; \text{map distance (cM)}$$

Two-point distances underestimate long distances because double crossovers between the two genes restore the parental combination and are not counted. For accurate maps, use short intervals and three-point crosses.

Three-point test cross: the standard procedure

  1. Identify the parental classes: the two largest reciprocal classes.
  2. Identify the double-crossover (DCO) classes: the two smallest.
  3. Find the middle gene: compare a DCO class with the parental class it most resembles. The one gene that is switched is the middle gene.
  4. Rewrite all classes in the correct order and assign single crossovers to region I or II.
  5. Distance for each region = (single crossovers in that region + all DCOs) / total × 100.
  6. Coefficient of coincidence (CoC) = observed DCO / expected DCO, where expected DCO = RF(I) × RF(II) × total.
  7. Interference (I) = 1 − CoC.
$$\text{CoC} = \frac{\text{observed DCO}}{\text{RF}_{I} \times \text{RF}_{II} \times N}, \qquad I = 1 - \text{CoC}$$
Interference valueMeaning
I = 0 (CoC = 1)Crossovers independent
0 < I < 1 (positive interference)One crossover reduces the chance of another nearby (usual)
I = 1 (CoC = 0)No double crossovers observed in the interval (complete interference)
I < 0 (negative interference)More doubles than expected (seen in some fungal and phage crosses over very short intervals)

Worked example

A female Drosophila heterozygous for three recessive mutations d, e, f is test-crossed to a d e f / d e f male. 1,000 progeny are classified by the alleles they received from the mother:

ClassNumber
d⁺ e f⁺359
d e⁺ f351
d⁺ e⁺ f⁺52
d e f48
d⁺ e f92
d e⁺ f⁺88
d e f⁺6
d⁺ e⁺ f4
  • Parentals: d⁺ e f⁺ and d e⁺ f.
  • DCOs: d e f⁺ and d⁺ e⁺ f. Compared with the parental d e⁺ f, the DCO d⁺ e⁺ f differs only at d. So d is in the middle: order e – d – f.
  • Region e–d (single crossovers swap e relative to d f): d⁺ e⁺ f⁺ and d e f = 100. Distance = (100 + 10)/1000 = 11 cM.
  • Region d–f (swap f relative to e d): d⁺ e f and d e⁺ f⁺ = 180. Distance = (180 + 10)/1000 = 19 cM.
  • e–f = 11 + 19 = 30 cM (a two-point estimate from the same data would give (100 + 180)/1000 = 28 cM, missing the doubles twice).
  • Expected DCO = 0.11 × 0.19 × 1000 = 20.9; CoC = 10/20.9 = 0.48; I = 0.52.

Mapping functions

Recombination frequency (r) is not additive over long distances because of multiple crossovers. A mapping function converts r to a map distance d (in morgans) that is additive:

FunctionAssumptionFormula
HaldaneNo interference (crossovers Poisson distributed)\(d = -\tfrac{1}{2}\ln(1 - 2r)\)
KosambiAllows interference (decreasing with distance)\(d = \tfrac{1}{4}\ln\dfrac{1 + 2r}{1 - 2r}\)

For r = 0.20: Haldane gives 25.5 cM, Kosambi 21.2 cM. Both approach r for small r. Under Haldane’s model, the probability of no crossover in an interval with mean m crossovers is \(e^{-m}\), and \(r = \tfrac{1}{2}(1 - e^{-m})\), which can never exceed 0.5.

Physical and genetic distance

Genetic distance (cM) is not proportional to physical distance (bp) everywhere: recombination is suppressed near centromeres and in heterochromatin, and concentrated in hotspots. The ratio of physical to genetic distance therefore varies along a chromosome and between species and sexes.


Tetrad Analysis

In fungi such as Neurospora crassa (ordered asci) and Saccharomyces cerevisiae (unordered tetrads), all four products of one meiosis can be recovered. This gives information unavailable from random spores: centromere distances, the four-strand nature of crossing over, and gene conversion.

Ordered tetrads (Neurospora): mapping a gene to its centromere

The ascus holds eight ascospores in a line (meiosis followed by one mitosis), so the order reflects the spindle orientation.

SegregationPattern in the octadCause
First-division (MI) segregationAAAA aaaa or aaaa AAAA (4 : 4)No crossover between the gene and its centromere
Second-division (MII) segregationAA aa AA aa, aa AA aa AA, AA aa aa AA, aa AA AA aaOne crossover between gene and centromere

So there are six possible arrangements: two MI and four MII.

$$\text{Gene–centromere distance (cM)} = \frac{1}{2} \times \frac{\text{MII asci}}{\text{total asci}} \times 100$$

The factor ½ appears because in an MII ascus only two of the four chromatids are recombinant. Example: 40 MII asci in 200 → ½ × 20% = 10 cM. The maximum MII frequency is about 2/3 (so the maximum measurable centromere distance by this method is about 33 cM), because multiple crossovers randomise the pattern.

Unordered tetrads (yeast): mapping two genes

For a cross AB × ab, each tetrad is one of three types:

Tetrad typeSporesArises from
Parental ditype (PD)2 AB : 2 abNo crossover between the genes (also two-strand double crossovers)
Non-parental ditype (NPD)2 Ab : 2 aBFour-strand double crossover (for linked genes)
Tetratype (T)AB, Ab, aB, abSingle crossover (also 3-strand doubles)
  • Unlinked genes (different chromosomes): PD ≈ NPD, because the two bivalents orient independently.
  • Linked genes: PD ≫ NPD, because NPD requires a rare four-strand double crossover.
$$\text{RF} = \frac{\text{NPD} + \tfrac{1}{2}\text{T}}{\text{total}} \times 100$$

Perkins’ formula corrects for undetected double crossovers (assuming no more than two crossovers in the interval and no chromatid interference):

$$d\ (\text{cM}) = \frac{50\,(\text{T} + 6\,\text{NPD})}{\text{total}}$$

Example: PD 70, NPD 2, T 28 (100 tetrads) → linked; RF = (2 + 14)/100 = 16 cM; Perkins = 50(28 + 12)/100 = 20 cM.


Mapping in Bacteria: Gene Transfer

Bacteria are haploid and do not undergo meiosis. Genes are mapped by transferring a piece of a donor genome into a recipient and selecting recombinants. Transferred DNA forms a partial diploid (merozygote); an even number of crossovers is needed to integrate it into the circular chromosome.

ProcessVehicleNeeds cell contact?Sensitive to DNase?Size transferred
TransformationFree DNANoYesSmall fragments
ConjugationPlasmid-directed transfer through a pilus/mating pairYesNoUp to the whole chromosome (Hfr)
TransductionPhage particleNoNo (DNA is inside the capsid)About one phage head-full

Transformation

  • Griffith (1928): heat-killed virulent (S, capsulated) pneumococci plus live non-virulent (R) cells killed mice, and live S bacteria were recovered: a “transforming principle”.
  • Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1944): the principle was destroyed by DNase but not by protease or RNase; it was DNA.
  • Natural competence in Streptococcus pneumoniae, Bacillus subtilis, Haemophilus influenzae (the last prefers DNA carrying its own uptake sequences). E. coli is made competent artificially (CaCl₂ and heat shock, or electroporation).
  • Mapping: genes close enough to be on the same fragment are co-transformed at a frequency far above the product of single transformation frequencies. If the double-transformant frequency at low DNA concentration falls in proportion to the DNA concentration (not its square), the genes are on one fragment.

Conjugation

StrainF factor stateCrossed with F⁻Chromosomal gene transfer
F⁺Autonomous plasmidRecipients become F⁺ at high frequencyVery rare
HfrIntegrated into the chromosome (by recombination between IS elements)Recipients usually stay F⁻High frequency, from oriT in a fixed direction; F is transferred last
F′Excised F carrying some chromosomal genesRecipients become F′ and partial diploids for those genesOnly the carried genes (“sexduction”)
  • Lederberg and Tatum (1946) obtained prototrophs from mixing two multiply auxotrophic E. coli strains; Davis’s U-tube experiment (filter between strains) showed that cell contact was required, distinguishing conjugation from transformation.
  • Interrupted mating (Wollman and Jacob): matings between an Hfr and an F⁻ are broken in a blender at intervals; each donor gene first appears among recombinants at a characteristic time of entry. The E. coli map is therefore measured in minutes (0–100 for the whole chromosome).
  • Different Hfr strains start at different points and in different directions, but all orders are parts of one circle: the classic proof that the E. coli map is circular.
  • Gradient of transfer: the later a gene enters, the lower its maximum recombinant frequency, because spontaneous interruption of the mating pair becomes more likely with time.
  • Selection: recombinants are selected for a donor marker that the recipient lacks, and the Hfr is counter-selected (for example with streptomycin, if the F⁻ is streptomycin resistant). The selected marker should enter late, so that earlier markers are present in all selected recombinants.
  • F′ merodiploids made the complementation and cis–trans tests possible in bacteria (the lac operon experiments).

Transduction

GeneralisedSpecialised
PhageP22 (Salmonella; Zinder and Lederberg, 1952), P1 (E. coli)λ (E. coli)
How it arisesHeadful packaging mistakes during lytic growth package a random host fragmentAberrant excision of a prophage takes adjacent host genes
Genes transferredAny host geneOnly genes next to the attachment site (gal or bio for λ)
Particle contentsHost DNA only (no phage genes)Hybrid phage–host DNA (e.g. λdgal, defective)
Lysate—Low-frequency (LFT) lysate; with a helper phage, high-frequency (HFT) lysate
  • Abortive transduction: the transduced fragment is not integrated and not replicated; it is passed to only one daughter cell at each division, giving a microcolony when it supplies a needed function.
  • Cotransduction frequency is high only for genes close enough to fit in one phage head. For P1 (which carries about 2 min of the E. coli chromosome), Wu’s formula relates cotransduction frequency C to distance d (in minutes) and transducing-fragment length L:
$$C = \left(1 - \frac{d}{L}\right)^{3}$$

Example: with L = 2 min, C = 0.343 gives \(1 - d/2 = 0.7\), so d = 0.6 min.

  • Ordering by cotransduction: if a–b and b–c are cotransduced often but a–c rarely or never, the order is a–b–c.

Phage crosses

Mixed infection of one host with two phage mutants (e.g. T4 h r⁺ × h⁺ r) gives recombinant plaques; RF = recombinant plaques / total plaques. Fine-structure mapping within one phage gene is described in Genes, Mutations and Fine-Structure Analysis.


Molecular Markers

A molecular marker is a DNA sequence variant whose position is known and whose alleles can be scored directly. Markers fill linkage maps far more densely than morphological mutants and are neutral (they do not alter the phenotype).

MarkerBasisDominanceMulti-allelic?Notes
RFLPRestriction digestion + Southern hybridisation with a probeCodominantUsually few allelesFirst DNA marker system used for human linkage maps; needs much DNA, slow
Minisatellite / VNTRTandem repeats of ~10–60 bp units, scored by Southern blot or PCRCodominantHighlyDNA fingerprinting (Jeffreys)
RAPDPCR with single short (10-mer) arbitrary primersDominantNoQuick, no sequence knowledge needed; poor reproducibility
AFLPRestriction (e.g. EcoRI + MseI), adapter ligation, selective PCRMostly dominantNoMany loci per reaction; reproducible
SSR (microsatellite)1–6 bp repeats; PCR with flanking primers; length polymorphismCodominantYes, highlyLocus-specific, abundant, transferable; widely used in plant breeding and forensics
ISSRPCR primed from SSRs, amplifying between themDominantNoNo sequence knowledge needed
SCARA RAPD/AFLP band converted to a specific PCR markerDominant or codominant—Reliable version of an anonymous band
CAPSPCR product digested by a restriction enzymeCodominant—Scores SNPs that alter a restriction site
SNPSingle-nucleotide variants; arrays, sequencing, genotyping-by-sequencingCodominantUsually biallelicMost abundant; high-throughput; basis of GWAS and genomic selection

Mapping Populations in Plants

Plants allow controlled crosses and selfing, so geneticists build populations designed for mapping.

PopulationHow it is madeMarker segregation (codominant)Permanent?Notes
F₂Self (or intercross) the F₁1 : 2 : 1No (each plant unique, segregating)Quick; estimates additive and dominance effects
Backcross (BC₁)F₁ × one parent1 : 1NoOne meiosis per gamete scored
Recombinant inbred lines (RILs)F₂ plants selfed by single-seed descent for many generations (F₆–F₈ and beyond)1 : 1 (homozygous)Yes (immortal; replicated trials)Several meioses accumulate recombination: apparent recombination R = 2r/(1 + 2r) for selfed RILs
Doubled haploids (DH)Haploids from F₁ gametes (anther or microspore culture, or wide crosses with chromosome elimination), chromosome doubling with colchicine1 : 1YesCompletely homozygous in one generation; one meiosis
Near-isogenic lines (NILs)Repeated backcrossing to a recurrent parent with selection for one trait or region—YesDiffer only around the target region; fine mapping and validation
Chromosome-segment substitution / introgression linesBackcrossing a donor (often wild) into an elite background—YesEach line carries one donor segment
Multi-parent populations (e.g. MAGIC, NAM)Inter-crossing several founders, or many founders each crossed to one reference parent—YesMore alleles and more recombination; higher resolution
Association (diversity) panelsUnrelated lines from germplasm—YesUse historical recombination (linkage disequilibrium) for GWAS

Bulked segregant analysis (BSA): DNA from the extreme phenotypic classes of a segregating population is pooled into two bulks; a marker that differs between the bulks is linked to the trait gene. It quickly finds markers linked to a single major gene without genotyping every individual.

How these populations are used to locate genes for continuous traits (QTL mapping) is covered in Quantitative and Population Genetics.


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Coefficient of coincidence (observed/expected DCO)vsInterference (1 − CoC)
MII segregation (crossover between gene and centromere)vsTetratype (crossover between two genes)
NPD in linked genes (four-strand double)vsNPD in unlinked genes (as frequent as PD)
F⁺ × F⁻ (recipient becomes F⁺; little chromosome transfer)vsHfr × F⁻ (chromosome transfer; recipient stays F⁻)
F′ (excised F with host genes; merodiploids)vsHfr (integrated F)
Generalised transduction (any gene; headful; P1, P22)vsSpecialised transduction (genes next to att; λ; aberrant excision)
Abortive transduction (not integrated; microcolony)vsComplete transduction (integrated by recombination)
Haldane (no interference)vsKosambi (allows interference)
RIL (many meioses; inflated apparent RF)vsDH (one meiosis; RF as in a backcross)
Dominant marker (RAPD, AFLP, ISSR)vsCodominant marker (RFLP, SSR, SNP, CAPS)

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. In a three-point test cross, which classes are used to identify the gene in the middle?
  2. Which bacterial gene-transfer process is sensitive to DNase added to the medium?
  3. Name two codominant and two dominant molecular markers.
Answers
  1. The double-crossover classes (the two rarest), compared with the parental classes (the two most frequent).
  2. Transformation.
  3. Codominant: RFLP, SSR, SNP, CAPS (any two). Dominant: RAPD, AFLP, ISSR (any two).

Level 2: Part B Style

Q1 (practice). In Neurospora, a cross a × a⁺ gives 300 asci, of which 255 show the 4 : 4 pattern and 45 show 2 : 2 : 2 : 2 or 2 : 4 : 2 patterns. The distance of gene a from its centromere is:

  • (a) 15 cM
  • (b) 7.5 cM
  • (c) 30 cM
  • (d) 3.75 cM
Answer and explanation

(b). MII asci = 45/300 = 15%; distance = ½ × 15 = 7.5 cM. (a) forgets the factor ½.

Q2 (practice). In a yeast cross AB × ab, 100 tetrads give PD = 45, NPD = 43, T = 12. The best conclusion is:

  • (a) A and B are tightly linked
  • (b) A and B are unlinked, and both lie close to their centromeres
  • (c) A and B are linked about 6 cM apart
  • (d) A and B are unlinked and both are far from their centromeres
Answer and explanation

(b). PD ≈ NPD means unlinked. Tetratypes for unlinked genes arise only when a crossover occurs between at least one gene and its centromere; very few T (12%) means both genes are close to their centromeres. If either gene were far from its centromere, T would be much more frequent (approaching about 2/3).

Q3 (practice). A P1 lysate grown on a leu⁺ ara⁺ donor is used to transduce a leu⁻ ara⁻ recipient. Of 500 Leu⁺ transductants, 245 are also Ara⁺ (cotransduction frequency 0.49). Using Wu’s formula with L = 2 min, the approximate distance between leu and ara is:

  • (a) 0.2 min
  • (b) 0.42 min
  • (c) 0.49 min
  • (d) 1.0 min
Answer and explanation

(b). \((1 - d/2)^3 = 0.49\) → \(1 - d/2 = 0.49^{1/3} = 0.788\) → \(d = 2 \times 0.212 = 0.42\) min. Note that cotransduction frequency falls as distance rises; it is not itself a distance.

Q4 (practice). Which mapping population is permanent, fully homozygous and produced in a single generation from F₁ gametes?

  • (a) F₂
  • (b) Recombinant inbred lines
  • (c) Doubled haploids
  • (d) Backcross population
Answer and explanation

(c) Doubled haploids. RILs are also permanent and (nearly) homozygous, but take several generations of selfing; F₂ and backcross populations are not permanent.

Level 3: Part C Style

Q1 (practice). A plant heterozygous for three linked recessive genes p, q, r is test-crossed and 2,000 progeny are scored (alleles received from the heterozygote):

ClassNumber
p q⁺ r⁺690
p⁺ q r710
p q r130
p⁺ q⁺ r⁺150
p q⁺ r152
p⁺ q r⁺148
p q r⁺9
p⁺ q⁺ r11

Determine (i) the gene order, (ii) the map distances, (iii) the coefficient of coincidence and interference.

Answer and worked solution

(i) Parentals: p q⁺ r⁺ and p⁺ q r. DCOs: p q r⁺ and p⁺ q⁺ r. Compare p⁺ q⁺ r with the parental p⁺ q r: only q differs. Compare p q r⁺ with p q⁺ r⁺: again only q. So q is in the middle: p – q – r.

(ii) Region p–q: crossover swaps p relative to q r. Parental p | q⁺ r⁺ → p⁺ q⁺ r⁺ and p q r: 150 + 130 = 280. Region q–r: swaps r relative to p q: p q⁺ r and p⁺ q r⁺: 152 + 148 = 300. DCO = 20. p–q = (280 + 20)/2000 = 15 cM; q–r = (300 + 20)/2000 = 16 cM; p–r = 31 cM.

(iii) Expected DCO = 0.15 × 0.16 × 2000 = 48. CoC = 20/48 = 0.42; I = 0.58 (positive interference).

Q2 (practice). Three Hfr strains of E. coli transfer genes in the following orders (earliest first), each strain transferring the first gene listed at about 1 min after mixing:

  • Hfr 1: thr – leu – azi – ton – pro
  • Hfr 2: pro – ton – azi – leu – thr
  • Hfr 3: lac – pro – ton – azi – leu

Which statements are correct?

(P) All three orders are consistent with a single circular map. (Q) Hfr 1 and Hfr 2 transfer in opposite directions. (R) In Hfr 3, lac lies between the F insertion site and pro. (S) For Hfr 1, selecting for pro⁺ recombinants (with the Hfr counter-selected) gives a population in which nearly all cells have also received thr⁺.

  • (a) P, Q and R only
  • (b) P, Q, R and S
  • (c) Q and S only
  • (d) P and R only
Answer and worked solution

(b) P, Q, R and S.

  • (P) The orders share the segment thr–leu–azi–ton–pro, read forwards (Hfr 1), backwards (Hfr 2), and with lac next to pro (Hfr 3): one circle, … thr leu azi ton pro lac …, is consistent with all.
  • (Q) Hfr 2 transfers the same genes in reverse: the F factor is integrated in the opposite orientation.
  • (R) Hfr 3 transfers lac first, then pro: lac lies between its origin and pro.
  • (S) pro is the last of the listed genes transferred by Hfr 1; any recipient that received it must have received everything before it, including thr (whether each entered marker is also integrated depends on crossovers, so “received” is the precise claim). This is why the selected marker in such crosses is chosen to be a late one.

Q3 (practice). A RIL population (selfed to near homozygosity) and a backcross population are derived from the same two parents. For two markers, the backcross gives a recombination fraction r = 0.10. What recombination fraction is expected among the RILs, and why is a RIL map “expanded”?

Answer and worked solution

For selfed RILs, \(R = \dfrac{2r}{1 + 2r} = \dfrac{0.2}{1.2} = 0.167\).

Each RIL passes through several rounds of meiosis while still heterozygous (in the F₁, F₂, F₃ …), so more crossovers accumulate than in the single meiosis sampled by a backcross or DH. The proportion of lines with recombinant marker combinations is therefore higher (here 16.7% instead of 10%). Mapping software converts R back to r, but if this is ignored the map looks expanded. The advantage is higher resolution per line for fine mapping.


Quick Revision Table

ItemFact
Map unit1% recombination = 1 cM; Sturtevant’s first map (1911–1913), additivity
Three-point crossParentals largest, DCO smallest; switched gene in DCO is middle; add DCO to both regions
CoC / interferenceCoC = obs/exp DCO; I = 1 − CoC; positive interference usual
Mapping functionsHaldane \(d = -\tfrac{1}{2}\ln(1-2r)\); Kosambi \(d = \tfrac{1}{4}\ln\frac{1+2r}{1-2r}\)
Ordered tetrads2 MI + 4 MII patterns; centromere distance = ½ × % MII; max MII ≈ 2/3
Unordered tetradsPD, NPD, T; linked PD ≫ NPD; unlinked PD ≈ NPD
Gene–gene distance(NPD + ½T)/total; Perkins 50(T + 6NPD)/total
Tetrads proveFour-strand crossing over; gene conversion (3 : 1, 6 : 2), post-meiotic segregation (5 : 3)
TransformationGriffith 1928; Avery–MacLeod–McCarty 1944; DNase-sensitive; co-transformation
ConjugationLederberg–Tatum 1946; U-tube (contact); F⁺, Hfr, F′; interrupted mating; map in minutes; circular
HfrIntegrated F; oriT; F transferred last; recipients stay F⁻; gradient of transfer
Generalised transductionP22 (Zinder–Lederberg 1952), P1; headful; any gene
Specialised transductionλ; gal/bio; aberrant excision; LFT and HFT lysates
CotransductionWu: C = (1 − d/L)³, L ≈ 2 min for P1
Abortive transductionNot integrated; linear inheritance; microcolonies
Codominant markersRFLP, SSR, SNP, CAPS, VNTR
Dominant markersRAPD, AFLP, ISSR
F₂ / BC / RIL / DH1:2:1 / 1:1 / 1:1 permanent / 1:1 permanent, one generation
RIL expansionR = 2r/(1 + 2r)
BSAPool extremes; find markers differing between bulks

Key Takeaways

What’s Next