Separation Axioms
CSIR NET topology: T0, T1, Hausdorff, regular, completely regular and normal spaces, Urysohn lemma, Tietze extension, and the counter-examples between them.
- 19 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Topological Spaces, Bases and Dense Sets: the cofinite, cocountable, lower limit and K-topologies, which supply every counter-example on this page.
- Subspace and Product Topology: the Sorgenfrey plane and the hereditary and product tables.
- Metric Spaces and Several Variables: the distance function \( d(x, A) \), which makes metric spaces normal.
The Hook: A Sequence with Every Real Number as a Limit
The Ladder
| Axiom | Name | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| \( T_0 \) | Kolmogorov | for \( x \ne y \), some open set contains one of them but not the other |
| \( T_1 \) | Fréchet | for \( x \ne y \), each has an open set missing the other |
| \( T_2 \) | Hausdorff | \( x \ne y \) have disjoint open neighbourhoods |
| \( T_3 \) | regular (+ \( T_1 \)) | a point \( x \) and a closed set \( C \not\ni x \) have disjoint open neighbourhoods |
| \( T_{3\frac{1}{2}} \) | completely regular, Tychonoff (+ \( T_1 \)) | for \( x \notin C \) closed, some continuous \( f : X \to [0, 1] \) has \( f(x) = 0 \), \( f(C) = \{1\} \) |
| \( T_4 \) | normal (+ \( T_1 \)) | disjoint closed sets have disjoint open neighbourhoods |
\( T_4 \Rightarrow T_{3\frac{1}{2}} \) is not obvious: it is Urysohn’s lemma, applied to the closed sets \( \{x\} \) and \( C \). Every other arrow is immediate once singletons are closed.
graph TD
M[Metrizable] --> N["Normal T4"]
CH[Compact Hausdorff] --> N
RL["Regular + Lindelof"] --> N
N --> CR["Completely regular T3.5"]
CR --> R["Regular T3"]
R --> H["Hausdorff T2"]
H --> T1[T1]
T1 --> T0[T0]
R2["Regular + second countable"] --> MThe last arrow is the Urysohn metrization theorem: a regular (\( T_1 \)) space with a countable basis is metrizable.
Useful reformulations
| Axiom | Equivalent forms |
|---|---|
| \( T_0 \) | distinct points have distinct closures: \( \overline{\{x\}} \ne \overline{\{y\}} \) |
| \( T_1 \) | every singleton is closed; every finite set is closed; the cofinite topology is coarser than \( \tau \) |
| \( T_2 \) | the diagonal \( \Delta = \{(x, x)\} \) is closed in \( X \times X \) |
| Regular | for every \( x \) and open \( U \ni x \) there is open \( V \) with \( x \in V \subseteq \overline{V} \subseteq U \) |
| Normal | for every closed \( A \) and open \( U \supseteq A \) there is open \( V \) with \( A \subseteq V \subseteq \overline{V} \subseteq U \) |
What Each Axiom Buys You
T1
- Finite sets are closed, so in a finite \( T_1 \) space every subset is closed: a finite \( T_1 \) space is discrete. On a finite set there is exactly one \( T_1 \) topology, and it is also the only Hausdorff one.
- \( x \) is a limit point of \( A \) iff every neighbourhood of \( x \) contains infinitely many points of \( A \). So a finite set has no limit points.
Hausdorff
The converse of 1 fails. In the cocountable topology on an uncountable set, only eventually constant sequences converge, so limits are unique, yet the space is not Hausdorff (any two non-empty open sets meet).
Regular and normal
- Metric spaces are normal. For disjoint closed \( A \), \( B \), the function
is continuous, equals 0 on \( A \) and 1 on \( B \); \( f^{-1}[0, \frac{1}{2}) \) and \( f^{-1}(\frac{1}{2}, 1] \) separate them.
- Compact Hausdorff spaces are normal, and so are regular Lindelöf spaces (in particular regular second-countable ones).
- Closed subspaces of normal spaces are normal; arbitrary subspaces need not be.
- Regularity, complete regularity and Hausdorffness pass to all subspaces and all products. Normality passes to neither in general.
Urysohn’s Lemma and Tietze’s Extension Theorem
(“If” is easy: pull back \( [0, \frac{1}{2}) \) and \( (\frac{1}{2}, 1] \). “Only if” is the real theorem; the proof builds open sets \( U_r \) indexed by dyadic rationals \( r \in [0, 1] \) with \( \overline{U_r} \subseteq U_s \) for \( r < s \).)
Both hypotheses matter:
- \( A \) must be closed. \( f(x) = \sin\frac{1}{x} \) on \( (0, 1] \subseteq \mathbb{R} \) is continuous and bounded, but has no continuous extension to \( [0, 1] \).
- Tietze implies normality. If every continuous map from every closed subset into \( [0, 1] \) extends, apply it to the function equal to 0 on \( A \) and 1 on \( B \) (continuous on the closed set \( A \cup B \)), and you get Urysohn’s function.
The Counter-example Table
| Space | \( T_0 \) | \( T_1 \) | \( T_2 \) | \( T_3 \) | \( T_4 \) | Reason it fails the next rung |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Indiscrete, \( \lvert X \rvert \ge 2 \) | no | no | no | no | no | no open set distinguishes two points |
| Sierpiński \( \{0, 1\} \), open: \( \varnothing, \{1\}, X \) | yes | no | no | no | no | \( \{1\} \) is not closed |
| Particular point topology, \( \lvert X \rvert \ge 2 \) | yes | no | no | no | no | every non-empty open set contains \( p \) |
| Cofinite, \( X \) infinite | yes | yes | no | no | no | two non-empty open sets always meet |
| Cocountable, \( X \) uncountable | yes | yes | no | no | no | two non-empty open sets always meet |
| \( \mathbb{R}_K \) | yes | yes | yes | no | no | \( 0 \) and the closed set \( K \) cannot be separated |
| Sorgenfrey plane \( \mathbb{R}_\ell^2 \) | yes | yes | yes | yes | no | anti-diagonal: rational and irrational points |
| \( \mathbb{R}_\ell \) | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | (normal) |
| Metric spaces, compact Hausdorff spaces | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes |
Two quick facts about continuous real functions
- Some \( T_1 \) spaces have only constant continuous real functions. On an uncountable set with the cocountable topology, any two non-empty open sets meet. If a continuous \( f \) took values \( a \ne b \), the preimages of disjoint intervals around \( a \) and \( b \) would be disjoint non-empty open sets. So every continuous \( f : X \to \mathbb{R} \) is constant, and the space is far from completely regular. The same argument works for the cofinite topology on an infinite set.
- In a completely regular space the continuous real functions determine the topology: \( X \) embeds in a cube \( [0, 1]^J \). This is why completely regular spaces are exactly the subspaces of compact Hausdorff spaces.
Preservation Summary
| Property | Subspaces | Products | Continuous images |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( T_0 \), \( T_1 \), \( T_2 \) | yes | yes | no (any space is a continuous image of a discrete space) |
| Regular, completely regular | yes | yes | no |
| Normal | closed subspaces only | no | no |
| Metrizable | yes | countable products | no |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| \( T_1 \): singletons closed | \( T_2 \): disjoint neighbourhoods | |
| unique sequential limits | Hausdorff (cocountable topology has the first, not the second) | |
| regular (point vs closed set) | normal (closed set vs closed set) | |
| Urysohn’s lemma (normal \( \Rightarrow \) separating functions) | Urysohn’s metrization theorem (regular + second countable \( \Rightarrow \) metrizable) | |
| Tietze for closed \( A \) | arbitrary \( A \) (fails: \( \sin\frac{1}{x} \) on \( (0, 1] \)) | |
| regular with \( T_1 \) (Munkres) | regular without \( T_1 \) (some texts) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. In Level 3, as in Part C, one or more options may be correct.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many \( T_1 \) topologies are there on a set with 5 elements?
- Is the cofinite topology on \( \mathbb{N} \) Hausdorff?
- State the hypotheses of the Tietze extension theorem.
Answers
- One, the discrete topology: in a finite \( T_1 \) space every subset is a finite union of closed singletons.
- No. Two non-empty open sets have finite complements, so they intersect (\( \mathbb{N} \) is infinite).
- \( X \) normal, \( A \subseteq X \) closed, \( f : A \to \mathbb{R} \) (or \( [a, b] \)) continuous.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The number of \( T_0 \) topologies on the set \( \{a, b, c\} \) is:
(a) 1 (b) 9 (c) 19 (d) 29
Answer: (c)
Of the 29 topologies on a 3-point set, 19 are \( T_0 \) (enumerated in Python). 1 is the number of \( T_1 \) topologies (only the discrete one), 9 the number of topologies up to homeomorphism, 29 the total.
A hand check of one non-\( T_0 \) case: \( \{\varnothing, \{a\}, X\} \) is not \( T_0 \) because no open set contains exactly one of \( b \), \( c \).
Practice Q2. Which of the following spaces is Hausdorff but not regular?
(a) \( \mathbb{R} \) with the cofinite topology (b) \( \mathbb{R}_K \) (c) \( \mathbb{R}_\ell \) (d) \( \mathbb{R} \) with the discrete topology
Answer: (b)
In \( \mathbb{R}_K \) the point 0 and the closed set \( K = \{\frac{1}{n}\} \) cannot be separated by disjoint open sets. (a) is not Hausdorff; (c) and (d) are normal.
Practice Q3. In \( \mathbb{R} \) with the cofinite topology, the sequence \( x_n = n \) converges to:
(a) no point (b) only 0 (c) every point of \( \mathbb{N} \) only (d) every real number
Answer: (d)
A neighbourhood \( U \) of any real \( p \) omits a finite set \( F \). The terms \( n \) are distinct, so only finitely many lie in \( F \); hence \( x_n \in U \) eventually. The sequence converges to every point, which is impossible in a Hausdorff space.
Practice Q4. Which space is normal, while its product with itself is not normal?
(a) \( \mathbb{R} \) (usual) (b) \( [0, 1] \) (c) \( \mathbb{R}_\ell \) (d) \( \mathbb{Q} \)
Answer: (c)
\( \mathbb{R}_\ell \) is normal (proof on this page); \( \mathbb{R}_\ell \times \mathbb{R}_\ell \) is not. The others are metric spaces, and finite products of metric spaces are metric, hence normal.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Let \( X \) and \( Y \) be topological spaces with \( Y \) Hausdorff. Which statements are true?
(a) If continuous \( f, g : X \to Y \) agree on a dense subset of \( X \), then \( f = g \). (b) The graph of every continuous \( f : X \to Y \) is closed in \( X \times Y \). (c) If \( X \) is finite and Hausdorff, then \( X \) is discrete. (d) If \( f : Y \to X \) is a continuous surjection, then \( X \) is Hausdorff.
Answer: (a), (b) and (c)
- (a) True. \( \{x : f(x) = g(x)\} \) is the preimage of the closed diagonal under \( x \mapsto (f(x), g(x)) \), so it is closed; it contains a dense set, so it is \( X \).
- (b) True. The graph is the preimage of the diagonal of \( Y \times Y \) under \( (x, y) \mapsto (f(x), y) \).
- (c) True. Hausdorff implies \( T_1 \); a finite \( T_1 \) space is discrete.
- (d) False. The identity from \( \mathbb{R} \) (usual) onto \( \mathbb{R} \) with the indiscrete topology is a continuous surjection onto a non-Hausdorff space.
Practice Q6. Let \( X \) be an uncountable set with the cocountable topology. Which statements are true?
(a) \( X \) is \( T_1 \). (b) \( X \) is Hausdorff. (c) Every convergent sequence in \( X \) has exactly one limit. (d) Every continuous function \( f : X \to \mathbb{R} \) is constant.
Answer: (a), (c) and (d)
- (a) True. Singletons are countable, hence closed.
- (b) False. Two non-empty open sets have countable complements; their intersection has countable complement in an uncountable set, so it is non-empty.
- (c) True. If \( x_n \to x \), the set \( S \) of terms different from \( x \) is countable, hence closed, and \( X \setminus S \) is a neighbourhood of \( x \); so \( x_n = x \) eventually. A sequence that is eventually equal to \( x \) cannot also be eventually equal to \( y \ne x \).
- (d) True. If \( f \) took two values, preimages of disjoint open intervals around them would be disjoint non-empty open sets, contradicting the argument in (b).
Practice Q7. Let \( A = \{0\} \cup \{\frac{1}{n} : n \in \mathbb{N}\} \subseteq \mathbb{R} \) and define \( g : A \to \mathbb{R} \) by \( g(\frac{1}{n}) = \frac{(-1)^n}{n} \), \( g(0) = 0 \). Which statements are true?
(a) \( g \) is continuous on \( A \). (b) \( g \) extends to a continuous function on \( \mathbb{R} \). (c) \( g \) extends to a continuous function \( \mathbb{R} \to [-\frac{1}{2}, \frac{1}{2}] \). (d) Every bounded continuous function on the open set \( (0, 1) \) extends to a continuous function on \( \mathbb{R} \).
Answer: (a) and (b)
- (a) True. The only non-isolated point of \( A \) is 0, and \( \lvert g(\frac{1}{n}) \rvert = \frac{1}{n} \to 0 = g(0) \).
- (b) True. \( A \) is closed in the normal space \( \mathbb{R} \), so Tietze applies. (Concretely: join consecutive points of the graph by line segments, and extend by constants outside \( [0, 1] \).)
- (c) False. \( g(1) = -1 \notin [-\frac{1}{2}, \frac{1}{2}] \), so no extension can take values there. Tietze gives an extension with values in \( [-1, \frac{1}{2}] \), the smallest closed interval containing the range of \( g \).
- (d) False. \( \sin\frac{1}{x} \) on \( (0, 1) \) is bounded and continuous, with no limit at 0.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| \( T_0 \) / \( T_1 \) / \( T_2 \) | one-sided / two-sided / disjoint neighbourhoods |
| \( T_1 \) test | singletons closed |
| \( T_2 \) test | diagonal closed in \( X \times X \) |
| Finite \( T_1 \) | discrete; one \( T_1 \) topology on a finite set |
| \( T_0 \) topologies on 3 points | 19 of 29 |
| Ladder | metrizable \( \Rightarrow T_4 \Rightarrow T_{3\frac{1}{2}} \Rightarrow T_3 \Rightarrow T_2 \Rightarrow T_1 \Rightarrow T_0 \) |
| Normal sources | metric; compact Hausdorff; regular Lindelöf |
| Gap examples | Sierpiński; cofinite; \( \mathbb{R}_K \); Sorgenfrey plane |
| Urysohn lemma | normal \( \iff \) disjoint closed sets separated by \( f : X \to [0, 1] \) |
| Tietze | normal, \( A \) closed: continuous \( A \to \mathbb{R} \) extends |
| Urysohn metrization | regular + \( T_1 \) + second countable \( \Rightarrow \) metrizable |
| Productive and hereditary | \( T_0 \) to \( T_{3\frac{1}{2}} \); not \( T_4 \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Connectedness: connected sets, components and path-connectedness, with the matrix-group questions Part C likes.
- Compactness: why compact Hausdorff spaces are normal, and the compact-to-Hausdorff homeomorphism theorem.
- Back to Subspace and Product Topology for the Sorgenfrey plane.
- The Topology chapter overview.