Skip to content

Hamilton–Jacobi Theory and Action-Angle Variables

CSIR NET advanced mechanics: Hamilton–Jacobi equation, characteristic functions, separation of variables, action-angle variables, adiabatic invariants.

  • 20 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Pendulum on a Shortening String
  3. The Hamilton–Jacobi Equation
  4. Worked Solutions
  5. Separation of Variables
  6. Action-Angle Variables
  7. Adiabatic Invariants
  8. Connections to Quantum Mechanics
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Pendulum on a Shortening String

The Hamilton–Jacobi Equation

Seek a type-2 generating function \( S(q, P, t) \) for which the new Hamiltonian is zero:

$$K = H\left(q, \frac{\partial S}{\partial q}, t\right) + \frac{\partial S}{\partial t} = 0$$

That is the Hamilton–Jacobi equation (HJE):

$$\boxed{H\left(q_1, \ldots, q_n,\ \frac{\partial S}{\partial q_1}, \ldots, \frac{\partial S}{\partial q_n},\ t\right) + \frac{\partial S}{\partial t} = 0}$$

With \( K = 0 \), the new momenta and coordinates are all constants: call them \( \alpha_i \) and \( \beta_i \). A complete integral is a solution \( S(q, \alpha, t) \) containing \( n \) independent non-additive constants \( \alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_n \). (An additive constant in \( S \) is irrelevant.) Then

$$\boxed{p_i = \frac{\partial S}{\partial q_i}, \qquad \beta_i = \frac{\partial S}{\partial\alpha_i}}$$

The second set of \( n \) equations, solved for \( q_i \), gives the trajectory \( q_i(t, \alpha, \beta) \); the first gives the momenta. The \( 2n \) constants are fixed by initial conditions.

What \( S \) is

Along an actual trajectory,

$$\frac{dS}{dt} = \sum_i\frac{\partial S}{\partial q_i}\dot q_i + \frac{\partial S}{\partial t} = \sum_ip_i\dot q_i - H = L$$

So \( S = \int L\,dt + \text{const} \): Hamilton’s principal function is the action, evaluated along the true path as a function of its end point. It satisfies \( \partial S/\partial q = p \) and \( \partial S/\partial t = -H \).

Time-independent Hamiltonians

If \( H \) has no explicit \( t \), separate time off:

$$S(q, \alpha, t) = W(q, \alpha) - Et$$

where Hamilton’s characteristic function \( W \) satisfies the time-independent HJE

$$\boxed{H\left(q, \frac{\partial W}{\partial q}\right) = E}$$

Take \( \alpha_1 = E \). The equation \( \beta_1 = \partial S/\partial E = \partial W/\partial E - t \) gives \( t \) as a function of position (the timing); the others, \( \beta_i = \partial W/\partial\alpha_i \) for \( i \geq 2 \), give the orbit shape without time.

FunctionArgumentsSatisfiesGenerates
Principal function \( S \)\( q, \alpha, t \)\( H + \partial S/\partial t = 0 \)\( K = 0 \): all new variables constant
Characteristic function \( W \)\( q, \alpha \)\( H(q, \partial W/\partial q) = E \)\( K = E \): new momenta constant, new coordinates linear in \( t \)

Worked Solutions

Separation of Variables

The HJE is useful because it often separates. Try \( W = \sum_iW_i(q_i) \). If a coordinate \( q_k \) appears in \( H \) only through a combination \( f_k(q_k, \partial W/\partial q_k) \) that can be set equal to a constant, it separates.

  • Cyclic coordinates separate trivially: if \( q_k \) is cyclic, \( W_k = \alpha_kq_k \) with \( \alpha_k = p_k \).
  • Separation constants are conserved quantities: \( E \), \( p_z \), \( L_z \), \( L^2 \) and so on. Each symmetry of Symmetry, Invariance and Noether’s Theorem supplies one.
  • Separability depends on the coordinates. The Kepler problem separates in spherical coordinates and also in parabolic coordinates (the second fact is why parabolic coordinates are used for hydrogen in a uniform electric field, the Stark problem).

Central force in a plane

$$H = \frac{p_r^2}{2m} + \frac{p_\theta^2}{2mr^2} + V(r)$$

\( \theta \) is cyclic, so \( W = \alpha_\theta\theta + W_r(r) \), with \( \alpha_\theta = L \), and

$$W_r = \int\sqrt{2m\left(E - V(r)\right) - \frac{L^2}{r^2}}\,dr$$

Then \( \partial W/\partial L = \beta_2 \) gives the orbit,

$$\theta - \beta_2 = \int\frac{L\,dr}{r^2\sqrt{2m(E - V) - L^2/r^2}}$$

which is the standard orbit integral, now obtained without writing a single equation of motion.

Central force in space

In spherical coordinates the HJE reads

$$\frac{1}{2m}\left[\left(\frac{\partial W}{\partial r}\right)^2 + \frac{1}{r^2}\left(\frac{\partial W}{\partial\theta}\right)^2 + \frac{1}{r^2\sin^2\theta}\left(\frac{\partial W}{\partial\phi}\right)^2\right] + V(r) = E$$

It separates in the order \( \phi \), then \( \theta \), then \( r \):

$$\frac{\partial W}{\partial\phi} = \alpha_\phi = L_z, \qquad \left(\frac{\partial W}{\partial\theta}\right)^2 + \frac{\alpha_\phi^2}{\sin^2\theta} = \alpha_\theta^2 = L^2, \qquad \frac{1}{2m}\left(\frac{\partial W}{\partial r}\right)^2 + \frac{\alpha_\theta^2}{2mr^2} + V = E$$

The three separation constants \( E \), \( L^2 \), \( L_z \) are the three commuting conserved quantities of a central force, the same ones that label hydrogen states by \( n, l, m \).

Action-Angle Variables

For a periodic motion (libration between turning points, or rotation of an angle-like coordinate) with one degree of freedom, define the action variable

$$\boxed{J = \oint p\,dq}$$

the area enclosed by the orbit in phase space, a function of \( E \) alone. Invert to get \( H = H(J) \). Use \( J \) as the new momentum; the conjugate angle variable is \( w = \partial W/\partial J \), and

$$\dot J = 0, \qquad \dot w = \frac{\partial H}{\partial J} \equiv \nu(J)$$

So \( w = \nu t + \beta \) and, over one period, \( w \) increases by exactly 1. Hence:

$$\boxed{\nu = \frac{\partial H}{\partial J} = \left(\frac{\partial J}{\partial E}\right)^{-1}, \qquad T = \frac{\partial J}{\partial E}}$$

The frequency comes from \( H(J) \) without solving the equation of motion.

Standard action variables

System\( J = \oint p\,dq \)\( H(J) \)Frequency \( \nu = \partial H/\partial J \)
Harmonic oscillator\( 2\pi E/\omega \)\( \omega J/2\pi \)\( \omega/2\pi \), independent of \( E \)
Particle in a box of width \( L \)\( 2L\sqrt{2mE} \)\( J^2/8mL^2 \)\( \sqrt{2E/m}/2L = v/2L \)
Ball bouncing on a floor in gravity \( g \)\( \dfrac{4\sqrt2}{3g\sqrt m}E^{3/2} \)\( \propto J^{2/3} \)\( \dfrac{g}{2}\sqrt{\dfrac{m}{2E}} = \dfrac{1}{2\sqrt{2h/g}} \)
Plane rotor, moment of inertia \( I \)\( 2\pi p_\phi \)\( J^2/8\pi^2I \)\( p_\phi/2\pi I = \dot\phi/2\pi \)
Power law \( V = a\lvert x\rvert^k \)\( \propto E^{1/2 + 1/k} \)\( \propto J^{2k/(k+2)} \)\( \propto E^{1/2 - 1/k} \)

The power-law row checks against mechanical similarity: for \( k = 2 \), \( \nu \) is independent of \( E \); for \( k = 4 \), \( \nu\propto E^{1/4}\propto \) amplitude (period halves when the amplitude doubles).

Several degrees of freedom and the Kepler degeneracy

For a separable system, define one action for each coordinate, \( J_i = \oint p_i\,dq_i \), and \( \nu_i = \partial H/\partial J_i \). For the Kepler problem with \( V = -k/r \), the energy depends on the actions only through their sum:

$$H = -\frac{2\pi^2mk^2}{(J_r + J_\theta + J_\phi)^2}$$

So all three frequencies are equal: \( \nu_r = \nu_\theta = \nu_\phi \). The radial and angular oscillations stay in step and the orbit closes, the same fact that the Runge–Lenz vector expresses. A frequency degeneracy of this kind is the action-angle signature of a hidden symmetry.

With \( J = J_r + J_\theta + J_\phi \), \( \nu = \partial H/\partial J = 4\pi^2mk^2/J^3 = 2\lvert E\rvert/J \). Setting \( J = nh \) (Bohr–Sommerfeld, below) with \( k = e^2/4\pi\varepsilon_0 \) gives \( E_n = -mk^2/2n^2\hbar^2 = -13.6\ \text{eV}/n^2 \), the Bohr levels.

Adiabatic Invariants

Let a parameter \( \lambda \) of the Hamiltonian (a length, a spring constant, a field) change slowly compared with the period: \( T\,\lvert\dot\lambda\rvert \ll \lvert\lambda\rvert \). Then the energy changes, but the action \( J \) stays constant (its changes are smaller than any power of the slowness). \( J \) is an adiabatic invariant.

Slow changeInvariantConsequence
Oscillator, \( \omega \) varied\( E/\omega \)\( E\propto\omega \)
Pendulum length \( l \) shortened\( E/\omega \), with \( \omega = \sqrt{g/l} \) and \( E = \tfrac{1}{2}mgl\theta_0^2 \)\( E\propto l^{-1/2} \), amplitude \( \theta_0\propto l^{-3/4} \)
Box width \( L \) changed\( L\sqrt E \)\( E\propto L^{-2} \); in 3D \( E\propto V^{-2/3} \), so \( PV^{5/3} = \) const for a monatomic ideal gas
Charge gyrating in a slowly varying \( \mathbf{B} \)\( mv_\perp^2/2B \) (magnetic moment), equivalently flux through the orbitmagnetic mirrors and trapping

The box result is the mechanical origin of the adiabatic law: a slow (quasi-static) compression of a monatomic ideal gas raises each particle’s energy as \( V^{-2/3} \), matching the \( \gamma = 5/3 \) adiabat of Laws of Thermodynamics, Entropy and Heat Engines.

Connections to Quantum Mechanics

Old quantum theory. Bohr and Sommerfeld quantised by setting \( \oint p\,dq = nh \). The adiabatic invariance of \( J \) made this consistent: a slow change cannot cause a jump between quantised values. The WKB approximation refines the rule to \( \oint p\,dq = (n + \tfrac{1}{2})h \) for smooth turning points, which is exact for the oscillator (\( E = (n + \tfrac{1}{2})\hbar\omega \)). For hard walls (the box) the correction changes: \( 2L\sqrt{2mE} = nh \) gives the exact box levels.

The classical limit. Write \( \psi = A\,e^{iS/\hbar} \) in the Schrödinger equation. The terms of order \( \hbar^0 \) give exactly the Hamilton–Jacobi equation for \( S \); the next order gives the continuity equation for \( A^2 \). Surfaces of constant \( S \) are wavefronts and trajectories are their normals, with \( \mathbf{p} = \nabla S \): Hamilton’s optical–mechanical analogy, completed by quantum mechanics. This is the basis of the WKB method in One-Dimensional Problems: Box, Oscillator and Tunnelling.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Principal function \( S(q, \alpha, t) \): \( K = 0 \)Characteristic function \( W(q, \alpha) \): \( K = E \)
\( p = \partial S/\partial q \)\( \beta = \partial S/\partial\alpha \) (new coordinate, constant)
Goldstein \( J = \oint p\,dq \), \( \nu = \partial H/\partial J \)Landau \( I = J/2\pi \), \( \omega = \partial H/\partial I \)
Adiabatic invariant \( J \) constantEnergy \( E \) changes under slow variation
Adiabatic in mechanics: slow compared with the periodAdiabatic in thermodynamics: no heat exchange (the two meet for the ideal gas)
Bohr–Sommerfeld \( \oint p\,dq = nh \)WKB \( (n + \tfrac{1}{2})h \) for smooth turning points

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Write the Hamilton–Jacobi equation for a free particle in one dimension.
  2. Give the action variable \( J = \oint p\,dq \) of a harmonic oscillator of energy \( E \) and angular frequency \( \omega \).
  3. For a time-independent Hamiltonian, how are \( S \) and \( W \) related?
Answers
  1. \( \dfrac{1}{2m}\left(\dfrac{\partial S}{\partial x}\right)^2 + \dfrac{\partial S}{\partial t} = 0 \).
  2. \( J = 2\pi E/\omega \) (the area of the phase-space ellipse).
  3. \( S = W - Et \).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. A particle of mass \( m \) moves back and forth between rigid walls a distance \( L \) apart with energy \( E \). Using action-angle variables, the frequency of the motion is:

(a) \( \dfrac{1}{L}\sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}} \) (b) \( \dfrac{1}{2L}\sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}} \) (c) \( \dfrac{1}{4L}\sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}} \) (d) \( \dfrac{E}{2\pi L} \)

Answer: (b)

\( J = 2L\sqrt{2mE} \Rightarrow E = J^2/8mL^2 \), and \( \nu = \partial E/\partial J = J/4mL^2 = 2L\sqrt{2mE}/4mL^2 = \dfrac{1}{2L}\sqrt{\dfrac{2E}{m}} \). Check: speed \( v = \sqrt{2E/m} \) and a round trip of length \( 2L \) gives \( \nu = v/2L \). Option (a) uses only half the loop.

Practice Q2. A simple pendulum swings with a small angular amplitude \( \theta_0 \). Its length is slowly reduced to one quarter of the original. The new amplitude is:

(a) \( \theta_0/4 \) (b) \( 2\theta_0 \) (c) \( 2^{3/2}\theta_0 \) (d) \( 4\theta_0 \)

Answer: (c)

\( E/\omega \) is invariant. \( E = \tfrac{1}{2}mgl\theta_0^2 \) and \( \omega = \sqrt{g/l} \), so \( E/\omega = \tfrac{1}{2}m\sqrt g\,l^{3/2}\theta_0^2 \) is constant and \( \theta_0\propto l^{-3/4} \). For \( l\to l/4 \): \( \theta_0\to4^{3/4}\theta_0 = 2^{3/2}\theta_0\approx2.83\,\theta_0 \).

Practice Q3. For a particle in \( V = ax^4 \), the frequency of oscillation depends on the energy as:

(a) \( \nu\propto E^{-1/4} \) (b) \( \nu\propto E^0 \) (c) \( \nu\propto E^{1/4} \) (d) \( \nu\propto E^{3/4} \)

Answer: (c)

\( J = 4\int_0^{x_0}\sqrt{2m(E - ax^4)}\,dx \) with \( x_0 = (E/a)^{1/4} \). Substituting \( x = x_0u \): \( J\propto\sqrt E\cdot E^{1/4} = E^{3/4} \). So \( E\propto J^{4/3} \) and \( \nu = dE/dJ\propto J^{1/3}\propto E^{1/4} \). Consistent with mechanical similarity: amplitude \( \propto E^{1/4} \) and \( T\propto(\text{amplitude})^{-1} \).

Practice Q4. For \( H = \dfrac{p_x^2 + p_y^2}{2m} + mgy \), a complete integral of the time-independent HJE is \( W = \alpha_xx + W_y(y) \) with:

(a) \( W_y = \displaystyle\int\sqrt{2m(E - mgy)}\,dy \) (b) \( W_y = \displaystyle\int\sqrt{2m(E - mgy) - \alpha_x^2}\,dy \) (c) \( W_y = \displaystyle\int\sqrt{2mE - \alpha_x^2}\,dy \) (d) \( W_y = \displaystyle\int\sqrt{2m(E + mgy) - \alpha_x^2}\,dy \)

Answer: (b)

\( x \) is cyclic, so \( \partial W/\partial x = \alpha_x = p_x \). Substituting: \( \dfrac{\alpha_x^2}{2m} + \dfrac{1}{2m}W_y'^2 + mgy = E \), so \( W_y' = \sqrt{2m(E - mgy) - \alpha_x^2} \). Then \( \partial W/\partial\alpha_x = \beta_2 \) gives the parabolic path and \( \partial W/\partial E - t = \beta_1 \) gives the timing.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Non-interacting particles move freely inside a cubical box whose walls are moved inward very slowly, compared with the time between wall collisions. Which statements are correct?

  1. Each particle’s energy scales as \( L^{-2} \), where \( L \) is the side of the box.
  2. When \( L \) is halved, the rate at which a given particle strikes one particular wall increases by a factor of 4.
  3. The action variable of each Cartesian degree of freedom decreases in proportion to \( L \).
  4. For a monatomic ideal gas made of such particles, \( PV^{5/3} \) stays constant.

(a) 1 and 4 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
  1. For each direction, \( J_x = 2L\lvert p_x\rvert \) is adiabatically invariant, so \( \lvert p_x\rvert\propto1/L \) and \( E\propto L^{-2} \). True.
  2. Collision rate on one wall \( = \lvert v_x\rvert/2L \). Halving \( L \) doubles \( \lvert v_x\rvert \) and halves \( 2L \): factor 4. True.
  3. The action is the adiabatic invariant; it does not change. False.
  4. Total energy \( U\propto L^{-2} = V^{-2/3} \), and for a monatomic ideal gas \( P = \frac{2U}{3V}\propto V^{-5/3} \). True.

Practice Q6. For the Kepler problem, \( H = -\dfrac{2\pi^2mk^2}{J^2} \) with \( J = J_r + J_\theta + J_\phi \). Applying \( J = nh \) to the electron in hydrogen (\( k = e^2/4\pi\varepsilon_0 \), \( \lvert E_1\rvert = 13.6 \) eV, \( h = 4.136\times10^{-15} \) eV s), the classical orbital frequency in the \( n = 1 \) orbit is closest to:

(a) \( 3.29\times10^{15} \) Hz (b) \( 6.58\times10^{15} \) Hz (c) \( 1.32\times10^{16} \) Hz (d) \( 2.07\times10^{16} \) Hz

Answer: (b)

\( \nu = \dfrac{\partial H}{\partial J} = \dfrac{4\pi^2mk^2}{J^3} = \dfrac{2\lvert E\rvert}{J} \). With \( J = h \) and \( \lvert E_1\rvert = 13.6 \) eV:

$$\nu_1 = \frac{2\times13.6}{4.136\times10^{-15}}\ \text{Hz} \approx 6.58\times10^{15}\ \text{Hz}$$

Option (a) is \( \lvert E_1\rvert/h \), the frequency of the series limit of the Lyman lines (half the orbital frequency). For large \( n \), the frequency emitted in an \( n\to n - 1 \) transition approaches \( 2\lvert E_n\rvert/nh \), the classical orbital frequency: Bohr’s correspondence principle.

Practice Q7. For \( H = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} + mgq \), take \( W = -\dfrac{2}{3g}\sqrt{\dfrac{2}{m}}(E - mgq)^{3/2} \) and \( S = W - Et \). Which statements are correct?

  1. \( \partial S/\partial q \) equals the momentum \( \sqrt{2m(E - mgq)} \) (on the upward part of the motion).
  2. \( \beta = \partial S/\partial E \) gives \( q = \dfrac{E}{mg} - \dfrac{g}{2}(t + \beta)^2 \).
  3. \( dS/dt \) along the motion equals \( H \).
  4. \( W \) is a complete integral because it contains one non-additive constant \( E \).

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
  1. \( \partial W/\partial q = -\dfrac{2}{3g}\sqrt{\dfrac{2}{m}}\cdot\dfrac{3}{2}(E - mgq)^{1/2}(-mg) = \sqrt{2m(E - mgq)} \). True (the positive root; the downward part uses the other sign).
  2. \( \partial S/\partial E = -\dfrac{1}{g}\sqrt{\dfrac{2}{m}}(E - mgq)^{1/2} - t = \beta \). So \( E - mgq = \dfrac{mg^2}{2}(t + \beta)^2 \), giving the stated \( q(t) \). True.
  3. \( dS/dt = L = T - V \), not \( H \). False.
  4. One degree of freedom needs one non-additive constant. True.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaResult
HJE\( H(q, \partial S/\partial q, t) + \partial S/\partial t = 0 \)
Solution\( p = \partial S/\partial q \), \( \beta = \partial S/\partial\alpha \)
Meaning of \( S \)action along the true path; \( dS/dt = L \)
Time-independent\( S = W - Et \), \( H(q, \partial W/\partial q) = E \)
Free particle\( S = m(x - x_0)^2/2(t - t_0) \)
Separationcyclic \( q_k \): \( W_k = \alpha_kq_k \); central force: \( E, L^2, L_z \)
Action\( J = \oint p\,dq \); \( \nu = \partial H/\partial J \)
Oscillator\( J = 2\pi E/\omega \)
Box\( J = 2L\sqrt{2mE} \), \( \nu = v/2L \)
Bouncing ball\( J\propto E^{3/2} \)
Kepler\( H = -2\pi^2mk^2/(J_r + J_\theta + J_\phi)^2 \); degenerate frequencies
Adiabatic invariant\( J \); pendulum \( \theta_0\propto l^{-3/4} \), \( E\propto l^{-1/2} \)
Quantum links\( \oint p\,dq = nh \); \( \psi\sim e^{iS/\hbar} \) gives the HJE as \( \hbar\to0 \)

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement