Symmetry, Invariance and Noether's Theorem
CSIR NET advanced mechanics: Noether's theorem with total-derivative symmetries, Galilean boosts, Runge–Lenz vector, mechanical similarity and generators.
- 20 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why Does the Kepler Ellipse Not Turn?
- Symmetries of a Lagrangian
- Noether’s Theorem
- The Hamiltonian View
- Gauge Freedom and the Magnetic Field
- Hidden Symmetry: the Laplace–Runge–Lenz Vector
- Mechanical Similarity
- Discrete Symmetries and Fields
- Integrability
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Lagrangian and Hamiltonian Mechanics, Conservation Laws: cyclic coordinates, the energy function \( h \) and the basic symmetry–conservation table.
- Poisson Brackets and Canonical Transformations: generators of infinitesimal canonical transformations.
- Central Forces, Scattering and Collisions: the Kepler problem, whose hidden symmetry appears below.
The Hook: Why Does the Kepler Ellipse Not Turn?
Symmetries of a Lagrangian
Consider a one-parameter family of transformations of the coordinates,
$$q_i \to q_i + \epsilon\,\xi_i(q, t), \qquad \epsilon \text{ small}$$There are two levels of invariance:
- Strict symmetry: \( L \) is unchanged to first order, \( \delta L = 0 \).
- Quasi-symmetry (symmetry up to a total derivative): \( \delta L = \epsilon\,\dfrac{d\Lambda}{dt} \) for some function \( \Lambda(q, t) \).
Both leave the equations of motion unchanged, because adding a total time derivative to \( L \) does not change the Euler–Lagrange equations. Both give a conserved quantity.
Noether’s Theorem
Proof. To first order,
$$\delta L = \sum_i\left(\frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i}\xi_i + \frac{\partial L}{\partial\dot q_i}\dot\xi_i\right)\epsilon$$On a solution, \( \partial L/\partial q_i = \dot p_i \), so \( \delta L = \epsilon\sum_i(\dot p_i\xi_i + p_i\dot\xi_i) = \epsilon\,\dfrac{d}{dt}\sum_ip_i\xi_i \). Setting this equal to \( \epsilon\,d\Lambda/dt \) gives \( \dfrac{d}{dt}\left(\sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda\right) = 0 \).
Including time. If time also shifts, \( t \to t + \epsilon\tau \), the conserved quantity becomes \( Q = \sum_ip_i\xi_i - h\tau - \Lambda \), with \( h = \sum p_i\dot q_i - L \). For a pure time translation (\( \xi = 0 \), \( \tau = 1 \), \( \Lambda = 0 \)) this gives conservation of \( h \): energy conservation is Noether’s theorem for time-translation symmetry.
Recipe
- Find a transformation that leaves the physics unchanged: often the potential depends on a combination of coordinates that some shift leaves fixed.
- Write \( \xi_i \) (the change of each coordinate per unit \( \epsilon \)).
- Compute \( \delta L \). If it is zero, \( \Lambda = 0 \); if it is a total derivative, identify \( \Lambda \).
- \( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda \).
The standard table, extended
| Symmetry | \( \xi \) | \( \Lambda \) | Conserved quantity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time translation | \( \tau = 1 \) | 0 | energy function \( h \) |
| Translation along \( \hat{\mathbf{n}} \) | \( \delta\mathbf{r}_a = \hat{\mathbf{n}} \) | 0 | \( \hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\mathbf{P} \) |
| Rotation about \( \hat{\mathbf{n}} \) | \( \delta\mathbf{r}_a = \hat{\mathbf{n}}\times\mathbf{r}_a \) | 0 | \( \hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\mathbf{L} \) |
| Galilean boost along \( x \) | \( \delta x_a = t \) | \( MX \) (total mass times centre-of-mass coordinate) | \( P_xt - MX \) |
| Screw (helical) motion, pitch \( 2\pi b \) | \( \delta\phi = 1 \), \( \delta z = b \) | 0 | \( L_z + bp_z \) |
| Translation along \( (2, -1, 0) \) for \( V(x + 2y, z) \) | \( \delta x = 2 \), \( \delta y = -1 \) | 0 | \( 2p_x - p_y \) |
Symmetry hidden by the choice of coordinates
A symmetry need not show up as a cyclic coordinate. For \( V = V(x + 2y, z) \), no Cartesian coordinate is cyclic, but the shift \( x \to x + 2\epsilon \), \( y \to y - \epsilon \) leaves \( x + 2y \) unchanged, so \( 2p_x - p_y \) is conserved. In rotated coordinates \( u = (x + 2y)/\sqrt5 \), \( v = (2x - y)/\sqrt5 \), \( v \) is cyclic and \( p_v = (2p_x - p_y)/\sqrt5 \), the same quantity up to a factor.
The Hamiltonian View
In phase space, a function \( G(q, p) \) generates the transformation \( \delta f = \epsilon\{f, G\} \), and the Hamiltonian changes by \( \delta H = \epsilon\{H, G\} \). So
$$\boxed{G \text{ generates a symmetry of } H \iff \{G, H\} = 0 \iff G \text{ is conserved}}$$This version is symmetric: the conserved quantity generates the symmetry, and the symmetry’s generator is the conserved quantity. Combined with Poisson’s theorem, the conserved quantities form a closed algebra. If \( L_x \) and \( L_y \) are conserved, so is \( \{L_x, L_y\} = L_z \), and the symmetry is the full rotation group.
For an explicitly time-dependent \( G \), the condition is \( \{G, H\} + \partial G/\partial t = 0 \). The boost charge \( Pt - MX \) is of this kind.
Gauge Freedom and the Magnetic Field
For a charge \( q \) in a uniform field \( \mathbf{B} = B\hat{\mathbf{z}} \), the physics is invariant under translations in \( x \) and \( y \) and rotations about \( z \). Which canonical momentum is conserved depends on the vector potential chosen, because \( H = (\mathbf{p} - q\mathbf{A})^2/2m \) inherits the symmetries of \( \mathbf{A} \), not of \( \mathbf{B} \).
| Gauge | \( \mathbf{A} \) | Cyclic coordinate | Conserved canonical momentum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Landau, \( x \)-dependent | \( (0, Bx, 0) \) | \( y \) | \( p_y = m\dot y + qBx \) |
| Landau, \( y \)-dependent | \( (-By, 0, 0) \) | \( x \) | \( p_x = m\dot x - qBy \) |
| Symmetric | \( \tfrac{1}{2}\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{r} \) | \( \phi \) | \( p_\phi = m\rho^2\dot\phi + \tfrac{1}{2}qB\rho^2 \) |
In each gauge the other translations are still symmetries, but of the quasi kind: shifting \( x \) in the gauge \( \mathbf{A} = (0, Bx, 0) \) changes \( L \) by a total derivative, and the Noether charge is \( p_x - qBy = m\dot x - qBy \) (here \( A_x = 0 \), so \( p_x = m\dot x \)). The same combination \( m\dot x - qBy \) is the conserved \( p_x \) of the second Landau gauge: the mechanical form of a Noether charge does not depend on the gauge. The two translation charges together locate the centre of the circular orbit.
Hidden Symmetry: the Laplace–Runge–Lenz Vector
For \( V = -k/r \), define
$$\boxed{\mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\,\hat{\mathbf{r}}}$$Its properties, each worth a statement in a Part C question:
- \( \dot{\mathbf{A}} = 0 \) for the inverse-square force only.
- \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \): \( \mathbf{A} \) lies in the orbital plane.
- \( \mathbf{A} \) points from the force centre towards the perihelion.
- \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \), where \( e \) is the eccentricity; equivalently \( A^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mEL^2 \). For a circular orbit, \( \mathbf{A} = 0 \).
- Taking \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{r} = Ar\cos\theta \) gives the orbit directly: \( \dfrac{L^2}{mkr} = 1 + e\cos\theta \).
Counting: \( \mathbf{L} \) (3), \( E \) (1) and \( \mathbf{A} \) (3) are seven quantities, but they obey two relations (\( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \) and the magnitude formula). Five independent constants, the maximum for three degrees of freedom (a trajectory in a 6D phase space is fixed by 5 constants plus a starting time). That is why the bound orbits are closed curves: the motion is superintegrable.
The Poisson brackets of \( \mathbf{L} \) and a suitably rescaled \( \mathbf{A} \) close on the algebra of four-dimensional rotations for bound orbits. The quantum version of this symmetry is the reason for the \( n^2 \) degeneracy of hydrogen in Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom.
Any small extra term in the potential (a \( 1/r^3 \) correction, the pull of other planets) breaks the symmetry. Then \( \mathbf{A} \) is no longer conserved but rotates slowly: the perihelion precesses.
Bertrand’s theorem states that among central potentials only \( V \propto -1/r \) and \( V \propto r^2 \) make every bounded orbit closed. The isotropic oscillator has its own extra conserved quantity, a symmetric tensor \( T_{ij} \propto p_ip_j + m^2\omega^2x_ix_j \).
Mechanical Similarity
Scaling symmetries of the equations of motion give results without integration. Suppose the potential is homogeneous of degree \( k \): \( V(\lambda\mathbf{r}) = \lambda^kV(\mathbf{r}) \). Scale lengths by \( \lambda \) and times by \( \mu \). The kinetic energy scales as \( \lambda^2/\mu^2 \) and the potential as \( \lambda^k \); the equations of motion are unchanged if these match, \( \mu = \lambda^{1 - k/2} \). So for geometrically similar paths,
$$\boxed{\frac{t'}{t} = \left(\frac{l'}{l}\right)^{1 - k/2}}, \qquad \frac{E'}{E} = \left(\frac{l'}{l}\right)^k$$| Potential | \( k \) | Time scaling | Physical statement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harmonic \( \propto r^2 \) | 2 | \( t \propto l^0 \) | period independent of amplitude |
| Uniform field \( \propto z \) | 1 | \( t \propto l^{1/2} \) | fall time \( \propto \sqrt{\text{height}} \) |
| Kepler \( \propto -1/r \) | \( -1 \) | \( t \propto l^{3/2} \) | Kepler’s third law \( T^2 \propto a^3 \) |
| Quartic \( \propto x^4 \) | 4 | \( t \propto l^{-1} \) | doubling amplitude halves the period |
| \( \propto 1/r^2 \) | \( -2 \) | \( t \propto l^2 \) | the scaling behind \( D = xp - 2Ht \) |
The virial theorem belongs to the same family: for bounded motion in a homogeneous potential of degree \( k \), \( 2\langle T\rangle = k\langle V\rangle \). Kepler: \( \langle T\rangle = -E \), \( \langle V\rangle = 2E \). Oscillator: \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle = E/2 \).
Discrete Symmetries and Fields
Discrete symmetries (parity \( \mathbf{r}\to-\mathbf{r} \), time reversal \( t\to-t \), exchange of identical particles) have no infinitesimal version and give no Noether charge in classical mechanics. They restrict the form of solutions instead: time-reversal invariance means a trajectory run backwards is also a solution, which fails with friction or a magnetic field (unless \( \mathbf{B} \) is also reversed). In quantum mechanics parity becomes a conserved two-valued quantum number.
Fields. For a Lagrangian density \( \mathcal{L}(\phi, \partial_\mu\phi) \), Noether’s theorem gives a conserved current \( \partial_\mu j^\mu = 0 \) for every continuous symmetry. Space-time translations give the energy–momentum tensor; a phase symmetry \( \phi\to e^{i\alpha}\phi \) of a complex field gives a conserved charge current. CSIR NET treats this mostly in the electromagnetic-theory context; the mechanics version above is what Part C tests.
Integrability
A system with \( n \) degrees of freedom is Liouville integrable if it has \( n \) independent conserved quantities in involution (all mutual Poisson brackets zero). Then the motion lies on an \( n \)-dimensional torus in phase space and can be described by action-angle variables, as in Hamilton–Jacobi Theory and Action-Angle Variables. Every one-degree-of-freedom conservative system is integrable (energy suffices). Central-force motion is integrable through \( E \), \( L^2 \) and \( L_z \), which are in involution. Generic two-degree-of-freedom systems are not, and can be chaotic.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Strict symmetry: \( \delta L = 0 \) | Quasi-symmetry: \( \delta L = \) total derivative; both give charges | |
| Cyclic coordinate (symmetry visible) | Symmetry visible only after a change of variables | |
| Canonical momentum \( m\dot{\mathbf{r}} + q\mathbf{A} \) (gauge-dependent) | Mechanical momentum \( m\dot{\mathbf{r}} \) | |
| Runge–Lenz conserved for \( -k/r \) only | \( \mathbf{L} \) conserved for every central potential | |
| Continuous symmetry: conserved quantity | Discrete symmetry: no classical conserved quantity | |
| Symmetry of the equations (scaling) | Symmetry of the Lagrangian (gives Noether charges) | |
| \( h \) conserved (no explicit \( t \) in \( L \)) | \( h = E \) (needs time-independent constraints too) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- For \( L = \tfrac{1}{2}m(\dot\rho^2 + \rho^2\dot\phi^2 + \dot z^2) - V(\rho, z) \), name two conserved quantities.
- For a Galilean boost of a closed system, what is \( \Lambda \)?
- What is the Runge–Lenz vector for a circular Kepler orbit?
Answers
- \( p_\phi = m\rho^2\dot\phi = L_z \) (\( \phi \) is cyclic) and the energy \( h = T + V \) (no explicit \( t \), time-independent coordinates).
- \( \Lambda = MX = \sum m_ax_a \), giving the conserved \( Pt - MX \).
- Zero, since \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \) and \( e = 0 \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A particle moves in the potential \( V = f(x + 2y,\ z) \). Which quantity is conserved?
(a) \( p_x + 2p_y \) (b) \( 2p_x - p_y \) (c) \( p_z \) (d) \( L_z \)
Answer: (b)
The shift \( \delta x = 2\epsilon \), \( \delta y = -\epsilon \) leaves \( x + 2y \) and \( z \) unchanged, so \( Q = 2p_x - p_y \). Check: \( \{2p_x - p_y, H\} = -(2\partial_x - \partial_y)f = -(2f_1 - 2f_1) = 0 \), where \( f_1 \) is the derivative of \( f \) with respect to its first argument. Option (a) is the gradient direction of \( x + 2y \), the direction along which \( V \) changes fastest.
Practice Q2. A particle moves in a potential \( V(\rho,\ \phi - z/b) \) in cylindrical coordinates, with \( b \) a constant length. The conserved quantity is:
(a) \( L_z \) (b) \( p_z \) (c) \( L_z + bp_z \) (d) \( L_z - p_z/b \)
Answer: (c)
\( \phi - z/b \) is invariant under \( \delta\phi = \epsilon \), \( \delta z = b\epsilon \) (a screw motion). Then \( Q = p_\phi\cdot1 + p_z\cdot b = L_z + bp_z \). Neither \( L_z \) nor \( p_z \) is conserved alone, since \( V \) depends on \( \phi \) and on \( z \).
Practice Q3. A particle oscillates in \( V = ax^4 \) with amplitude \( A \) and period \( T \). If the amplitude is doubled, the period becomes:
(a) \( 4T \) (b) \( 2T \) (c) \( T \) (d) \( T/2 \)
Answer: (d)
\( k = 4 \), so \( t \propto l^{1 - k/2} = l^{-1} \). Doubling the amplitude halves the period. Physically, the restoring force grows as \( x^3 \), so larger swings are much faster.
Practice Q4. A charge \( q \) moves in a uniform field \( \mathbf{B} = B\hat{\mathbf{z}} \), described with \( \mathbf{A} = (0, Bx, 0) \). Which canonical momenta are conserved?
(a) \( p_x \) and \( p_y \) (b) \( p_y \) and \( p_z \) (c) \( p_x \) and \( p_z \) (d) only \( p_z \)
Answer: (b)
\( H = \dfrac{p_x^2 + (p_y - qBx)^2 + p_z^2}{2m} \) contains \( x \) but not \( y \) or \( z \). So \( p_y = m\dot y + qBx \) and \( p_z \) are conserved; \( \dot p_x = qB(p_y - qBx)/m = qB\dot y \neq 0 \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For a particle in \( V = -k/r \), with \( \mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\hat{\mathbf{r}} \), which statements are correct?
- \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \).
- \( A^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mEL^2 \).
- If a small term \( -\beta/r^3 \) is added to the potential, \( \mathbf{A} \) remains conserved because the force is still central.
- \( \mathbf{A} \) points from the force centre to the aphelion.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 2 and 3 only
Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only
- \( \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} \) is perpendicular to \( \mathbf{L} \), and \( \hat{\mathbf{r}}\perp\mathbf{L} \). True.
- Expanding \( A^2 = (\mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L})^2 - 2mk\,\hat{\mathbf{r}}\cdot(\mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L}) + m^2k^2 = p^2L^2 - 2mkL^2/r + m^2k^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mL^2\left(\frac{p^2}{2m} - \frac{k}{r}\right) \). True.
- Central forces conserve \( \mathbf{L} \), not \( \mathbf{A} \). The \( 1/r^3 \) term breaks the hidden symmetry and \( \mathbf{A} \) precesses. False.
- It points to the perihelion: at closest approach \( \mathbf{p}\perp\mathbf{r} \), and \( \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} \) points radially outward with magnitude \( pL = L^2/r \), which exceeds \( mk \) there (\( L^2/mkr_{\min} = 1 + e > 1 \)), so \( \mathbf{A} \) is along \( +\hat{\mathbf{r}} \) at perihelion. False.
Practice Q6. For \( H = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} + \dfrac{\alpha}{x^2} \) (\( \alpha > 0 \)), which of the following are constants of motion?
- \( H \)
- \( xp \)
- \( xp - 2Ht \)
- \( mx^2 - 2xpt + 2Ht^2 \)
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 1 and 2 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 3 and 4 only
- No explicit \( t \). True.
- \( \{xp, H\} = 2H \neq 0 \). False.
- \( \dot D = 2H - 2H = 0 \). True.
- Let \( K = mx^2 - 2xpt + 2Ht^2 \). Then \( \{mx^2, H\} = 2xp \); \( \{xp, H\} = 2H \); \( \partial K/\partial t = -2xp + 4Ht \). So \( \dot K = 2xp - 2t(2H) + 0 - 2xp + 4Ht = 0 \). True. (With \( H \) and \( D \), this third integral reflects the special conformal symmetry of the inverse-square potential; it gives \( x^2(t) \) as a quadratic in \( t \) directly.)
Practice Q7. Two particles of masses \( m_1 = 1 \) kg and \( m_2 = 3 \) kg move on a line with interaction \( V(x_1 - x_2) \) only. At \( t = 0 \): \( x_1 = 0 \), \( x_2 = 4 \) m, \( p_1 = 2 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \), \( p_2 = 6 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \). Using the boost charge, the centre-of-mass position at \( t = 5 \) s is:
(a) 3 m (b) 13 m (c) 10 m (d) 23 m
Answer: (b) 13 m
\( M = 4 \) kg, \( P = 8 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \) (conserved, translation symmetry). \( X(0) = (1\times0 + 3\times4)/4 = 3 \) m.
The boost charge \( Pt - MX \) is conserved: at \( t = 0 \) it is \( -MX(0) = -12 \). At \( t = 5 \): \( 8\times5 - 4X = -12 \Rightarrow X = 13 \) m. Equivalently \( X = X(0) + (P/M)t = 3 + 2\times5 = 13 \) m. The interaction \( V \) never enters.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Result |
|---|---|
| Noether | \( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda \), with \( \delta L = \epsilon\,d\Lambda/dt \) |
| With time shift | \( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - h\tau - \Lambda \) |
| Hamiltonian form | \( G \) conserved \( \iff \{G, H\} = 0 \) (plus \( \partial_tG \) if explicit) |
| Boost | \( Pt - MX \) conserved; centre of mass moves uniformly |
| Helix \( V(\rho, \phi - z/b) \) | \( L_z + bp_z \) |
| Magnetic field | conserved canonical momenta depend on the gauge |
| Runge–Lenz | \( \mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\hat{\mathbf{r}} \); \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \); towards perihelion |
| Bertrand | only \( -1/r \) and \( r^2 \) close all bound orbits |
| Similarity | \( t'/t = (l'/l)^{1 - k/2} \) |
| Virial | \( 2\langle T\rangle = k\langle V\rangle \) |
| Inverse-square potential | \( D = xp - 2Ht \) conserved |
| Integrable | \( n \) independent integrals in involution |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Hamilton–Jacobi Theory and Action-Angle Variables: separation of variables uses exactly these conserved quantities as separation constants.
- Poisson Brackets and Canonical Transformations: revisit generators with Noether in mind.
- Hamilton’s Principle and the Principle of Least Action: the variational principle behind the theorem, as Mathematical Sciences tests it.
- Classical Mechanics (Advanced): Quick Revision.