Skip to content

Symmetry, Invariance and Noether's Theorem

CSIR NET advanced mechanics: Noether's theorem with total-derivative symmetries, Galilean boosts, Runge–Lenz vector, mechanical similarity and generators.

  • 20 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 17 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Why Does the Kepler Ellipse Not Turn?
  3. Symmetries of a Lagrangian
  4. Noether’s Theorem
  5. The Hamiltonian View
  6. Gauge Freedom and the Magnetic Field
  7. Hidden Symmetry: the Laplace–Runge–Lenz Vector
  8. Mechanical Similarity
  9. Discrete Symmetries and Fields
  10. Integrability
  11. Memory Tricks
  12. Don’t Confuse
  13. Common Mistakes
  14. Practice
  15. Quick Revision Table
  16. Key Takeaways
  17. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Why Does the Kepler Ellipse Not Turn?

Symmetries of a Lagrangian

Consider a one-parameter family of transformations of the coordinates,

$$q_i \to q_i + \epsilon\,\xi_i(q, t), \qquad \epsilon \text{ small}$$

There are two levels of invariance:

  • Strict symmetry: \( L \) is unchanged to first order, \( \delta L = 0 \).
  • Quasi-symmetry (symmetry up to a total derivative): \( \delta L = \epsilon\,\dfrac{d\Lambda}{dt} \) for some function \( \Lambda(q, t) \).

Both leave the equations of motion unchanged, because adding a total time derivative to \( L \) does not change the Euler–Lagrange equations. Both give a conserved quantity.

Noether’s Theorem

Proof. To first order,

$$\delta L = \sum_i\left(\frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i}\xi_i + \frac{\partial L}{\partial\dot q_i}\dot\xi_i\right)\epsilon$$

On a solution, \( \partial L/\partial q_i = \dot p_i \), so \( \delta L = \epsilon\sum_i(\dot p_i\xi_i + p_i\dot\xi_i) = \epsilon\,\dfrac{d}{dt}\sum_ip_i\xi_i \). Setting this equal to \( \epsilon\,d\Lambda/dt \) gives \( \dfrac{d}{dt}\left(\sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda\right) = 0 \).

Including time. If time also shifts, \( t \to t + \epsilon\tau \), the conserved quantity becomes \( Q = \sum_ip_i\xi_i - h\tau - \Lambda \), with \( h = \sum p_i\dot q_i - L \). For a pure time translation (\( \xi = 0 \), \( \tau = 1 \), \( \Lambda = 0 \)) this gives conservation of \( h \): energy conservation is Noether’s theorem for time-translation symmetry.

Recipe

  1. Find a transformation that leaves the physics unchanged: often the potential depends on a combination of coordinates that some shift leaves fixed.
  2. Write \( \xi_i \) (the change of each coordinate per unit \( \epsilon \)).
  3. Compute \( \delta L \). If it is zero, \( \Lambda = 0 \); if it is a total derivative, identify \( \Lambda \).
  4. \( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda \).

The standard table, extended

Symmetry\( \xi \)\( \Lambda \)Conserved quantity
Time translation\( \tau = 1 \)0energy function \( h \)
Translation along \( \hat{\mathbf{n}} \)\( \delta\mathbf{r}_a = \hat{\mathbf{n}} \)0\( \hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\mathbf{P} \)
Rotation about \( \hat{\mathbf{n}} \)\( \delta\mathbf{r}_a = \hat{\mathbf{n}}\times\mathbf{r}_a \)0\( \hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\mathbf{L} \)
Galilean boost along \( x \)\( \delta x_a = t \)\( MX \) (total mass times centre-of-mass coordinate)\( P_xt - MX \)
Screw (helical) motion, pitch \( 2\pi b \)\( \delta\phi = 1 \), \( \delta z = b \)0\( L_z + bp_z \)
Translation along \( (2, -1, 0) \) for \( V(x + 2y, z) \)\( \delta x = 2 \), \( \delta y = -1 \)0\( 2p_x - p_y \)

Symmetry hidden by the choice of coordinates

A symmetry need not show up as a cyclic coordinate. For \( V = V(x + 2y, z) \), no Cartesian coordinate is cyclic, but the shift \( x \to x + 2\epsilon \), \( y \to y - \epsilon \) leaves \( x + 2y \) unchanged, so \( 2p_x - p_y \) is conserved. In rotated coordinates \( u = (x + 2y)/\sqrt5 \), \( v = (2x - y)/\sqrt5 \), \( v \) is cyclic and \( p_v = (2p_x - p_y)/\sqrt5 \), the same quantity up to a factor.

The Hamiltonian View

In phase space, a function \( G(q, p) \) generates the transformation \( \delta f = \epsilon\{f, G\} \), and the Hamiltonian changes by \( \delta H = \epsilon\{H, G\} \). So

$$\boxed{G \text{ generates a symmetry of } H \iff \{G, H\} = 0 \iff G \text{ is conserved}}$$

This version is symmetric: the conserved quantity generates the symmetry, and the symmetry’s generator is the conserved quantity. Combined with Poisson’s theorem, the conserved quantities form a closed algebra. If \( L_x \) and \( L_y \) are conserved, so is \( \{L_x, L_y\} = L_z \), and the symmetry is the full rotation group.

For an explicitly time-dependent \( G \), the condition is \( \{G, H\} + \partial G/\partial t = 0 \). The boost charge \( Pt - MX \) is of this kind.

Gauge Freedom and the Magnetic Field

For a charge \( q \) in a uniform field \( \mathbf{B} = B\hat{\mathbf{z}} \), the physics is invariant under translations in \( x \) and \( y \) and rotations about \( z \). Which canonical momentum is conserved depends on the vector potential chosen, because \( H = (\mathbf{p} - q\mathbf{A})^2/2m \) inherits the symmetries of \( \mathbf{A} \), not of \( \mathbf{B} \).

Gauge\( \mathbf{A} \)Cyclic coordinateConserved canonical momentum
Landau, \( x \)-dependent\( (0, Bx, 0) \)\( y \)\( p_y = m\dot y + qBx \)
Landau, \( y \)-dependent\( (-By, 0, 0) \)\( x \)\( p_x = m\dot x - qBy \)
Symmetric\( \tfrac{1}{2}\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{r} \)\( \phi \)\( p_\phi = m\rho^2\dot\phi + \tfrac{1}{2}qB\rho^2 \)

In each gauge the other translations are still symmetries, but of the quasi kind: shifting \( x \) in the gauge \( \mathbf{A} = (0, Bx, 0) \) changes \( L \) by a total derivative, and the Noether charge is \( p_x - qBy = m\dot x - qBy \) (here \( A_x = 0 \), so \( p_x = m\dot x \)). The same combination \( m\dot x - qBy \) is the conserved \( p_x \) of the second Landau gauge: the mechanical form of a Noether charge does not depend on the gauge. The two translation charges together locate the centre of the circular orbit.

Hidden Symmetry: the Laplace–Runge–Lenz Vector

For \( V = -k/r \), define

$$\boxed{\mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\,\hat{\mathbf{r}}}$$

Its properties, each worth a statement in a Part C question:

  1. \( \dot{\mathbf{A}} = 0 \) for the inverse-square force only.
  2. \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \): \( \mathbf{A} \) lies in the orbital plane.
  3. \( \mathbf{A} \) points from the force centre towards the perihelion.
  4. \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \), where \( e \) is the eccentricity; equivalently \( A^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mEL^2 \). For a circular orbit, \( \mathbf{A} = 0 \).
  5. Taking \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{r} = Ar\cos\theta \) gives the orbit directly: \( \dfrac{L^2}{mkr} = 1 + e\cos\theta \).

Counting: \( \mathbf{L} \) (3), \( E \) (1) and \( \mathbf{A} \) (3) are seven quantities, but they obey two relations (\( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \) and the magnitude formula). Five independent constants, the maximum for three degrees of freedom (a trajectory in a 6D phase space is fixed by 5 constants plus a starting time). That is why the bound orbits are closed curves: the motion is superintegrable.

The Poisson brackets of \( \mathbf{L} \) and a suitably rescaled \( \mathbf{A} \) close on the algebra of four-dimensional rotations for bound orbits. The quantum version of this symmetry is the reason for the \( n^2 \) degeneracy of hydrogen in Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom.

Any small extra term in the potential (a \( 1/r^3 \) correction, the pull of other planets) breaks the symmetry. Then \( \mathbf{A} \) is no longer conserved but rotates slowly: the perihelion precesses.

Bertrand’s theorem states that among central potentials only \( V \propto -1/r \) and \( V \propto r^2 \) make every bounded orbit closed. The isotropic oscillator has its own extra conserved quantity, a symmetric tensor \( T_{ij} \propto p_ip_j + m^2\omega^2x_ix_j \).

Mechanical Similarity

Scaling symmetries of the equations of motion give results without integration. Suppose the potential is homogeneous of degree \( k \): \( V(\lambda\mathbf{r}) = \lambda^kV(\mathbf{r}) \). Scale lengths by \( \lambda \) and times by \( \mu \). The kinetic energy scales as \( \lambda^2/\mu^2 \) and the potential as \( \lambda^k \); the equations of motion are unchanged if these match, \( \mu = \lambda^{1 - k/2} \). So for geometrically similar paths,

$$\boxed{\frac{t'}{t} = \left(\frac{l'}{l}\right)^{1 - k/2}}, \qquad \frac{E'}{E} = \left(\frac{l'}{l}\right)^k$$
Potential\( k \)Time scalingPhysical statement
Harmonic \( \propto r^2 \)2\( t \propto l^0 \)period independent of amplitude
Uniform field \( \propto z \)1\( t \propto l^{1/2} \)fall time \( \propto \sqrt{\text{height}} \)
Kepler \( \propto -1/r \)\( -1 \)\( t \propto l^{3/2} \)Kepler’s third law \( T^2 \propto a^3 \)
Quartic \( \propto x^4 \)4\( t \propto l^{-1} \)doubling amplitude halves the period
\( \propto 1/r^2 \)\( -2 \)\( t \propto l^2 \)the scaling behind \( D = xp - 2Ht \)

The virial theorem belongs to the same family: for bounded motion in a homogeneous potential of degree \( k \), \( 2\langle T\rangle = k\langle V\rangle \). Kepler: \( \langle T\rangle = -E \), \( \langle V\rangle = 2E \). Oscillator: \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle = E/2 \).

Discrete Symmetries and Fields

Discrete symmetries (parity \( \mathbf{r}\to-\mathbf{r} \), time reversal \( t\to-t \), exchange of identical particles) have no infinitesimal version and give no Noether charge in classical mechanics. They restrict the form of solutions instead: time-reversal invariance means a trajectory run backwards is also a solution, which fails with friction or a magnetic field (unless \( \mathbf{B} \) is also reversed). In quantum mechanics parity becomes a conserved two-valued quantum number.

Fields. For a Lagrangian density \( \mathcal{L}(\phi, \partial_\mu\phi) \), Noether’s theorem gives a conserved current \( \partial_\mu j^\mu = 0 \) for every continuous symmetry. Space-time translations give the energy–momentum tensor; a phase symmetry \( \phi\to e^{i\alpha}\phi \) of a complex field gives a conserved charge current. CSIR NET treats this mostly in the electromagnetic-theory context; the mechanics version above is what Part C tests.

Integrability

A system with \( n \) degrees of freedom is Liouville integrable if it has \( n \) independent conserved quantities in involution (all mutual Poisson brackets zero). Then the motion lies on an \( n \)-dimensional torus in phase space and can be described by action-angle variables, as in Hamilton–Jacobi Theory and Action-Angle Variables. Every one-degree-of-freedom conservative system is integrable (energy suffices). Central-force motion is integrable through \( E \), \( L^2 \) and \( L_z \), which are in involution. Generic two-degree-of-freedom systems are not, and can be chaotic.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Strict symmetry: \( \delta L = 0 \)Quasi-symmetry: \( \delta L = \) total derivative; both give charges
Cyclic coordinate (symmetry visible)Symmetry visible only after a change of variables
Canonical momentum \( m\dot{\mathbf{r}} + q\mathbf{A} \) (gauge-dependent)Mechanical momentum \( m\dot{\mathbf{r}} \)
Runge–Lenz conserved for \( -k/r \) only\( \mathbf{L} \) conserved for every central potential
Continuous symmetry: conserved quantityDiscrete symmetry: no classical conserved quantity
Symmetry of the equations (scaling)Symmetry of the Lagrangian (gives Noether charges)
\( h \) conserved (no explicit \( t \) in \( L \))\( h = E \) (needs time-independent constraints too)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. For \( L = \tfrac{1}{2}m(\dot\rho^2 + \rho^2\dot\phi^2 + \dot z^2) - V(\rho, z) \), name two conserved quantities.
  2. For a Galilean boost of a closed system, what is \( \Lambda \)?
  3. What is the Runge–Lenz vector for a circular Kepler orbit?
Answers
  1. \( p_\phi = m\rho^2\dot\phi = L_z \) (\( \phi \) is cyclic) and the energy \( h = T + V \) (no explicit \( t \), time-independent coordinates).
  2. \( \Lambda = MX = \sum m_ax_a \), giving the conserved \( Pt - MX \).
  3. Zero, since \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \) and \( e = 0 \).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. A particle moves in the potential \( V = f(x + 2y,\ z) \). Which quantity is conserved?

(a) \( p_x + 2p_y \) (b) \( 2p_x - p_y \) (c) \( p_z \) (d) \( L_z \)

Answer: (b)

The shift \( \delta x = 2\epsilon \), \( \delta y = -\epsilon \) leaves \( x + 2y \) and \( z \) unchanged, so \( Q = 2p_x - p_y \). Check: \( \{2p_x - p_y, H\} = -(2\partial_x - \partial_y)f = -(2f_1 - 2f_1) = 0 \), where \( f_1 \) is the derivative of \( f \) with respect to its first argument. Option (a) is the gradient direction of \( x + 2y \), the direction along which \( V \) changes fastest.

Practice Q2. A particle moves in a potential \( V(\rho,\ \phi - z/b) \) in cylindrical coordinates, with \( b \) a constant length. The conserved quantity is:

(a) \( L_z \) (b) \( p_z \) (c) \( L_z + bp_z \) (d) \( L_z - p_z/b \)

Answer: (c)

\( \phi - z/b \) is invariant under \( \delta\phi = \epsilon \), \( \delta z = b\epsilon \) (a screw motion). Then \( Q = p_\phi\cdot1 + p_z\cdot b = L_z + bp_z \). Neither \( L_z \) nor \( p_z \) is conserved alone, since \( V \) depends on \( \phi \) and on \( z \).

Practice Q3. A particle oscillates in \( V = ax^4 \) with amplitude \( A \) and period \( T \). If the amplitude is doubled, the period becomes:

(a) \( 4T \) (b) \( 2T \) (c) \( T \) (d) \( T/2 \)

Answer: (d)

\( k = 4 \), so \( t \propto l^{1 - k/2} = l^{-1} \). Doubling the amplitude halves the period. Physically, the restoring force grows as \( x^3 \), so larger swings are much faster.

Practice Q4. A charge \( q \) moves in a uniform field \( \mathbf{B} = B\hat{\mathbf{z}} \), described with \( \mathbf{A} = (0, Bx, 0) \). Which canonical momenta are conserved?

(a) \( p_x \) and \( p_y \) (b) \( p_y \) and \( p_z \) (c) \( p_x \) and \( p_z \) (d) only \( p_z \)

Answer: (b)

\( H = \dfrac{p_x^2 + (p_y - qBx)^2 + p_z^2}{2m} \) contains \( x \) but not \( y \) or \( z \). So \( p_y = m\dot y + qBx \) and \( p_z \) are conserved; \( \dot p_x = qB(p_y - qBx)/m = qB\dot y \neq 0 \).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. For a particle in \( V = -k/r \), with \( \mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\hat{\mathbf{r}} \), which statements are correct?

  1. \( \mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{L} = 0 \).
  2. \( A^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mEL^2 \).
  3. If a small term \( -\beta/r^3 \) is added to the potential, \( \mathbf{A} \) remains conserved because the force is still central.
  4. \( \mathbf{A} \) points from the force centre to the aphelion.

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 2 and 3 only

Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only
  1. \( \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} \) is perpendicular to \( \mathbf{L} \), and \( \hat{\mathbf{r}}\perp\mathbf{L} \). True.
  2. Expanding \( A^2 = (\mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L})^2 - 2mk\,\hat{\mathbf{r}}\cdot(\mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L}) + m^2k^2 = p^2L^2 - 2mkL^2/r + m^2k^2 = m^2k^2 + 2mL^2\left(\frac{p^2}{2m} - \frac{k}{r}\right) \). True.
  3. Central forces conserve \( \mathbf{L} \), not \( \mathbf{A} \). The \( 1/r^3 \) term breaks the hidden symmetry and \( \mathbf{A} \) precesses. False.
  4. It points to the perihelion: at closest approach \( \mathbf{p}\perp\mathbf{r} \), and \( \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} \) points radially outward with magnitude \( pL = L^2/r \), which exceeds \( mk \) there (\( L^2/mkr_{\min} = 1 + e > 1 \)), so \( \mathbf{A} \) is along \( +\hat{\mathbf{r}} \) at perihelion. False.

Practice Q6. For \( H = \dfrac{p^2}{2m} + \dfrac{\alpha}{x^2} \) (\( \alpha > 0 \)), which of the following are constants of motion?

  1. \( H \)
  2. \( xp \)
  3. \( xp - 2Ht \)
  4. \( mx^2 - 2xpt + 2Ht^2 \)

(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 1 and 2 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 3 and 4 only
  1. No explicit \( t \). True.
  2. \( \{xp, H\} = 2H \neq 0 \). False.
  3. \( \dot D = 2H - 2H = 0 \). True.
  4. Let \( K = mx^2 - 2xpt + 2Ht^2 \). Then \( \{mx^2, H\} = 2xp \); \( \{xp, H\} = 2H \); \( \partial K/\partial t = -2xp + 4Ht \). So \( \dot K = 2xp - 2t(2H) + 0 - 2xp + 4Ht = 0 \). True. (With \( H \) and \( D \), this third integral reflects the special conformal symmetry of the inverse-square potential; it gives \( x^2(t) \) as a quadratic in \( t \) directly.)

Practice Q7. Two particles of masses \( m_1 = 1 \) kg and \( m_2 = 3 \) kg move on a line with interaction \( V(x_1 - x_2) \) only. At \( t = 0 \): \( x_1 = 0 \), \( x_2 = 4 \) m, \( p_1 = 2 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \), \( p_2 = 6 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \). Using the boost charge, the centre-of-mass position at \( t = 5 \) s is:

(a) 3 m (b) 13 m (c) 10 m (d) 23 m

Answer: (b) 13 m

\( M = 4 \) kg, \( P = 8 \) kg m s\( ^{-1} \) (conserved, translation symmetry). \( X(0) = (1\times0 + 3\times4)/4 = 3 \) m.

The boost charge \( Pt - MX \) is conserved: at \( t = 0 \) it is \( -MX(0) = -12 \). At \( t = 5 \): \( 8\times5 - 4X = -12 \Rightarrow X = 13 \) m. Equivalently \( X = X(0) + (P/M)t = 3 + 2\times5 = 13 \) m. The interaction \( V \) never enters.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaResult
Noether\( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - \Lambda \), with \( \delta L = \epsilon\,d\Lambda/dt \)
With time shift\( Q = \sum p_i\xi_i - h\tau - \Lambda \)
Hamiltonian form\( G \) conserved \( \iff \{G, H\} = 0 \) (plus \( \partial_tG \) if explicit)
Boost\( Pt - MX \) conserved; centre of mass moves uniformly
Helix \( V(\rho, \phi - z/b) \)\( L_z + bp_z \)
Magnetic fieldconserved canonical momenta depend on the gauge
Runge–Lenz\( \mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - mk\hat{\mathbf{r}} \); \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = mke \); towards perihelion
Bertrandonly \( -1/r \) and \( r^2 \) close all bound orbits
Similarity\( t'/t = (l'/l)^{1 - k/2} \)
Virial\( 2\langle T\rangle = k\langle V\rangle \)
Inverse-square potential\( D = xp - 2Ht \) conserved
Integrable\( n \) independent integrals in involution

Key Takeaways

What’s Next