Charged Particles in Static Uniform Electric and Magnetic Fields
CSIR NET charged-particle dynamics: uniform E and B, cyclotron motion, helices, E×B drift, cycloids, relativistic orbits, cyclotron and mass spectrometer.
- 18 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: J. J. Thomson’s Tube
- The Equation of Motion
- Uniform Electric Field
- Uniform Magnetic Field
- Crossed Uniform Fields: E × B Drift
- Parallel E and B
- Applications
- Lagrangian, Hamiltonian and Canonical Momentum
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Magnetostatics and Electromagnetic Induction: the Lorentz force and the fact that magnetic forces do no work.
- Maxwell’s Equations, Potentials and Gauge Invariance: the vector potential, needed for the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian.
- Linear first-order ODEs with constant coefficients; the substitution \( w = v_x + iv_y \) turns two coupled equations into one.
- Relativistic momentum \( \mathbf p = \gamma m\mathbf v \) and energy \( E^2 = p^2c^2 + m^2c^4 \).
- Hamilton’s canonical equations in the Mathematical Sciences notes, for the canonical-momentum section.
The Hook: J. J. Thomson’s Tube
The Equation of Motion
$$\boxed{\frac{d\mathbf p}{dt} = q\left(\mathbf E + \mathbf v\times\mathbf B\right), \qquad \frac{d\mathcal E}{dt} = q\mathbf E\cdot\mathbf v}$$with \( \mathbf p = \gamma m\mathbf v \) and \( \mathcal E = \gamma mc^2 \). Only the electric field changes the energy. In a pure magnetic field the speed, and therefore \( \gamma \), is constant.
The equations are linear in \( \mathbf v \) at non-relativistic speeds, so the motion in combined fields is a superposition of the simple motions below.
Uniform Electric Field
Non-relativistic: a projectile
The charge accelerates uniformly at \( q\mathbf E/m \). Entering a field \( E\hat y \) with velocity \( v_0\hat x \):
$$y = \frac{qE}{2mv_0^2}x^2$$a parabola, exactly like a projectile under gravity. After plates of length \( L \), the beam leaves at angle \( \tan\theta = qEL/mv_0^2 \), and on a screen a further distance \( D \) beyond the plates the deflection is
$$Y = \frac{qEL}{mv_0^2}\left(\frac{L}{2} + D\right)$$as if the beam had been bent at the centre of the plates. If the particle was accelerated from rest through a potential \( V_a \), \( mv_0^2 = 2qV_a \) and \( Y = \dfrac{EL}{2V_a}\left(\dfrac{L}{2} + D\right) \): independent of charge and mass. An electrostatic deflection cannot separate particles that were accelerated by the same voltage.
Energy gained through a potential difference \( V \) is \( qV \). For an electron, 1 eV \( = 1.602\times10^{-19} \) J.
Relativistic: hyperbolic motion
From rest in a uniform field the momentum grows linearly, \( p = qEt \), but the speed cannot exceed \( c \):
$$v(t) = \frac{qEt}{\sqrt{m^2 + (qEt/c)^2}}, \qquad x(t) = \frac{mc^2}{qE}\left[\sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{qEt}{mc}\right)^2} - 1\right]$$The world line is a hyperbola in the \( x \)–\( ct \) plane, hence “hyperbolic motion”. For small \( t \) it reduces to \( x = \frac{1}{2}(qE/m)t^2 \).
Uniform Magnetic Field
Circular and helical motion
The force \( q\mathbf v\times\mathbf B \) is perpendicular to \( \mathbf v \); for \( \mathbf v \perp \mathbf B \) the orbit is a circle:
$$\boxed{r = \frac{mv}{qB} = \frac{p}{qB}, \qquad \omega_c = \frac{qB}{m}, \qquad T = \frac{2\pi m}{qB}}$$The cyclotron frequency is independent of speed and radius (non-relativistically). Faster particles go round larger circles in the same time.
With a velocity component \( v_\parallel \) along \( \mathbf B \), that component is untouched and the path is a helix:
$$r = \frac{mv_\perp}{qB}, \qquad \text{pitch } = v_\parallel T = \frac{2\pi mv_\parallel}{qB}$$Sense of rotation. The angular velocity vector is \( \boldsymbol\omega = -q\mathbf B/m \). Positive charges circle clockwise when viewed from the side toward which \( \mathbf B \) points (looking against \( \mathbf B \)); electrons circle anticlockwise. Either way the current loop formed by the orbit has a magnetic moment opposite to \( \mathbf B \): gyrating charges are diamagnetic, \( \mu = mv_\perp^2/2B \) antiparallel to \( \mathbf B \).
| Particle | \( f_c = qB/2\pi m \) per tesla |
|---|---|
| Electron | about 28.0 GHz |
| Proton | about 15.2 MHz |
A convenient form of \( e/m_e \) is \( 1.759\times10^{11} \) C kg\( ^{-1} \).
Solving it in one line
For \( \mathbf B = B\hat z \): \( \dot v_x = \omega_cv_y \), \( \dot v_y = -\omega_cv_x \) (for \( q > 0 \)). With \( w = v_x + iv_y \), \( \dot w = -i\omega_cw \), so \( w = w_0e^{-i\omega_ct} \): uniform rotation at \( \omega_c \). This complex trick also handles the crossed-field case below.
Relativistic orbits
Since \( \gamma \) is constant, simply replace \( m \) by \( \gamma m \):
$$r = \frac{p}{qB} = \frac{\gamma mv}{qB}, \qquad \omega = \frac{qB}{\gamma m}$$The frequency now falls as the energy rises. In practical units, for a singly charged particle,
$$\boxed{p\ [\text{GeV}/c] = 0.2998\,B\ [\text{T}]\,r\ [\text{m}]}$$so a 1 GeV/\( c \) particle in a 1 T field has a radius of 3.34 m. Measuring track curvature in a known field gives momentum: this is how particle detectors measure it.
Beyond uniform fields: the magnetic moment as an adiabatic invariant
If \( \mathbf B \) varies slowly in space or time compared with one gyration, the magnetic moment \( \mu = mv_\perp^2/2B \) is approximately conserved. Moving into a stronger field, \( v_\perp \) rises and, since speed is conserved, \( v_\parallel \) falls: the particle can be reflected (a magnetic mirror). Particles with pitch angle \( \sin^2\theta < B_0/B_{\max} \) escape (the loss cone). The Earth’s radiation belts trap particles this way.
Crossed Uniform Fields: E × B Drift
Take \( \mathbf E = E\hat y \) and \( \mathbf B = B\hat z \), with \( E < cB \). Go to a frame moving with velocity
$$\boxed{\mathbf v_d = \frac{\mathbf E\times\mathbf B}{B^2}}, \qquad v_d = \frac{E}{B}$$In that frame (non-relativistically) the electric force is cancelled by \( q\mathbf v_d\times\mathbf B \), and the particle simply gyrates at \( \omega_c \). Back in the lab, the motion is gyration plus a uniform drift:
- The drift is independent of charge, sign and mass: electrons and ions drift together, so no current flows in a neutral plasma from this drift.
- It is perpendicular to both \( \mathbf E \) and \( \mathbf B \), not along \( \mathbf E \).
- Its speed \( E/B \) is the speed selected by a velocity selector (Wien filter): particles moving at exactly \( E/B \) in the drift direction go straight.
The cycloid
A charge released from rest at the origin has initial velocity \( -\mathbf v_d \) in the drift frame, so it gyrates with speed \( v_d \) about a centre that drifts at \( v_d \). The result is a cycloid, the path of a point on the rim of a rolling wheel:
$$x = \frac{E}{B\omega_c}(\omega_ct - \sin\omega_ct), \qquad y = \frac{E}{B\omega_c}(1 - \cos\omega_ct)$$| Feature | Value |
|---|---|
| Maximum displacement along \( \mathbf E \) | \( \boxed{y_{\max} = \dfrac{2E}{B\omega_c} = \dfrac{2mE}{qB^2}} \) |
| Distance between cusps | \( 2\pi E/B\omega_c = 2\pi mE/qB^2 \) |
| Speed range | 0 at the cusps to \( 2E/B \) at the top |
| Average velocity | \( E/B \) along \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B \) |
Energy check: at the top, \( \frac{1}{2}m(2E/B)^2 = qEy_{\max} \), consistent with \( y_{\max} = 2mE/qB^2 \).
If the particle’s initial speed relative to the drift frame (\( \lvert\mathbf v_0 - \mathbf v_d\rvert \)) is less than \( v_d \), the path is a curtate trochoid (no cusps, no loops); if it is greater than \( v_d \), a prolate trochoid (with loops). Starting with exactly \( \mathbf v_d \), the path is a straight line.
The relativistic picture
\( \mathbf E\cdot\mathbf B \) and \( E^2 - c^2B^2 \) are Lorentz invariants. For crossed fields \( \mathbf E\cdot\mathbf B = 0 \), and:
- \( E < cB \): there is a frame (moving at \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B/B^2 \)) where \( \mathbf E' = 0 \). The motion is a gyration plus drift.
- \( E > cB \): there is a frame where \( \mathbf B' = 0 \). The particle is accelerated without bound along the electric field in that frame; no bounded drift exists.
- \( E = cB \): the fields look like a plane wave; neither can be removed.
Parallel E and B
With \( \mathbf E \parallel \mathbf B \parallel \hat z \), the components decouple: uniform acceleration \( qE/m \) along \( z \) and unchanged circular motion in the \( xy \)-plane. The path is a helix of increasing pitch, with the same (non-relativistic) period. For a general static field, split \( \mathbf E \) into components parallel and perpendicular to \( \mathbf B \): the parallel part accelerates along \( \mathbf B \), the perpendicular part causes the \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B \) drift.
Applications
| Device | Principle | Key formula |
|---|---|---|
| Thomson \( e/m \) tube | balance, then deflect | \( v = E/B \); deflection gives \( q/m \) |
| Velocity selector (Wien filter) | crossed fields | passes \( v = E/B \) |
| Mass spectrometer (magnetic sector) | ions from voltage \( V \) bend in \( B \) | \( r = \dfrac{1}{B}\sqrt{\dfrac{2mV}{q}} \propto \sqrt m \) |
| Bainbridge mass spectrograph | selector (\( E, B \)) then deflecting field \( B' \) | \( r = \dfrac{mE}{qBB'} \propto m \) |
| Cyclotron | fixed frequency \( qB/2\pi m \) across the dees | \( K_{\max} = \dfrac{q^2B^2R^2}{2m} \) |
| Hall effect | carriers drift sideways until \( qE_H = qvB \) | \( V_H = \dfrac{IB}{nqt} \); sign gives carrier type |
| Magnetic focusing | all helices from a point refocus after one period | focus length \( 2\pi mv_\parallel/qB \) |
Cyclotron limits. The resonance condition uses the non-relativistic frequency. As \( \gamma \) grows the particles fall out of step with the fixed RF, which limits a classical cyclotron to modest energies for protons and makes it useless for electrons (which become relativistic at a few hundred keV). The synchrocyclotron lowers the RF frequency during acceleration; the isochronous cyclotron shapes \( B \) to rise with radius.
Lagrangian, Hamiltonian and Canonical Momentum
The force law follows from
$$L = \frac{1}{2}m\mathbf v^2 - qV + q\mathbf v\cdot\mathbf A, \qquad \mathbf p_{\text{can}} = \frac{\partial L}{\partial\mathbf v} = m\mathbf v + q\mathbf A$$$$H = \frac{(\mathbf p_{\text{can}} - q\mathbf A)^2}{2m} + qV$$The canonical momentum is not \( m\mathbf v \), and it is gauge-dependent. In the Landau gauge \( \mathbf A = Bx\,\hat y \) for \( \mathbf B = B\hat z \), \( y \) is cyclic, so \( p_y = mv_y + qBx \) is conserved: this fixes the \( x \)-coordinate of the orbit centre. In quantum mechanics the same Hamiltonian gives the Landau levels \( E_n = (n + \tfrac{1}{2})\hbar\omega_c \) (plus \( p_z^2/2m \)), a harmonic-oscillator spectrum; compare One-Dimensional Problems: Box, Oscillator and Tunnelling.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Cyclotron frequency \( qB/m \), independent of \( v \) (non-relativistic) | Relativistic \( qB/\gamma m \), falls with energy | |
| \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B \) drift: independent of \( q \), \( m \) | Gyration radius and frequency: depend on \( q/m \) | |
| Drift perpendicular to \( \mathbf E \) | Uniform-\( \mathbf E \) acceleration along \( \mathbf E \) | |
| Radius \( r = mv_\perp/qB \) | Pitch \( 2\pi mv_\parallel/qB \) | |
| Canonical momentum \( m\mathbf v + q\mathbf A \) | Kinetic momentum \( m\mathbf v \), gauge-invariant | |
| Magnetic sector: \( r \propto \sqrt m \) at fixed \( V \) | Bainbridge (after a selector): \( r \propto m \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Write the non-relativistic cyclotron angular frequency. Does it depend on speed?
- In a velocity selector with crossed fields \( E \) and \( B \), which speed passes undeflected?
- A charge moves with momentum \( p \) perpendicular to a uniform field \( B \). Give the orbit radius, valid at any speed.
Answers
- \( \omega_c = qB/m \); no, it is independent of speed (non-relativistically).
- \( v = E/B \), moving along \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B \).
- \( r = p/qB \), with \( p = \gamma mv \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A proton of kinetic energy 1 MeV moves perpendicular to a uniform field of 1 T. The radius of its orbit is approximately:
(a) 1.4 cm (b) 7.2 cm (c) 14.4 cm (d) 28.9 cm
Answer: (c) 14.4 cm
\( p = \sqrt{2m_pK} = \sqrt{2\times1.673\times10^{-27}\times1.602\times10^{-13}} = 2.32\times10^{-20} \) kg m/s. \( r = p/eB = 2.32\times10^{-20}/1.602\times10^{-19} = 0.144 \) m. (At 1 MeV against a rest energy of 938 MeV, the non-relativistic formula is adequate.) Option (b) is half the correct radius; option (d), twice it, is the diameter.
Practice Q2. The cyclotron frequency \( f_c \) of an electron in a field of 0.1 T is about:
(a) 280 MHz (b) 1.76 GHz (c) 2.8 GHz (d) 17.6 GHz
Answer: (c) 2.8 GHz
\( f_c = eB/2\pi m_e = 1.759\times10^{11}\times0.1/2\pi = 2.80\times10^9 \) Hz. Option (d) is \( \omega_c \) in rad/s quoted as a frequency; option (b) is \( e/m_e \) times \( B \) with a power of ten lost.
Practice Q3. In crossed fields \( E = 10^4 \) V/m and \( B = 0.1 \) T, an electron and a proton are released from rest. Their average drift velocities are:
(a) \( 10^5 \) m/s for both, in the same direction (b) \( 10^5 \) m/s for both, in opposite directions (c) different speeds because their masses differ (d) zero for both, since they start at rest
Answer: (a)
\( v_d = E/B = 10^5 \) m/s along \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B \), independent of charge sign and mass. The electron’s cycloid is smaller (\( y_{\max} \propto m \)) and lies on the other side of the starting line, but both drift together.
Practice Q4. A singly charged particle with momentum 3 GeV/\( c \) moves perpendicular to a 1.5 T field. Its radius of curvature is about:
(a) 0.67 m (b) 2.0 m (c) 6.7 m (d) 20 m
Answer: (c) 6.7 m
\( r = p/(0.2998B) = 3/(0.2998\times1.5) = 6.67 \) m. The answer depends only on momentum and charge, not on which particle it is.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. An electron is released from rest at the origin in uniform fields \( \mathbf E = 10^3\,\hat y \) V/m and \( \mathbf B = 10^{-2}\,\hat z \) T. Consider:
- Its average velocity is \( 10^5 \) m/s along \( \hat x \).
- Its maximum speed is \( 2\times10^5 \) m/s.
- Its largest distance from the \( x \)-axis is about 0.11 mm.
- It moves into the region \( y > 0 \).
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Statement 1: \( \mathbf E\times\mathbf B/B^2 = (E/B)(\hat y\times\hat z) = 10^5\,\hat x \) m/s, for any charge. True.
Statement 2: the cycloid reaches \( 2v_d = 2\times10^5 \) m/s. True.
Statement 3: \( y_{\max} = \dfrac{2m_eE}{eB^2} = \dfrac{2\times9.109\times10^{-31}\times10^3}{1.602\times10^{-19}\times10^{-4}} = 1.14\times10^{-4} \) m. True.
Statement 4: the force on an electron at rest is \( -e\mathbf E \), along \( -\hat y \). It moves into \( y < 0 \). False.
Practice Q6. A cyclotron with dee radius 0.5 m operates with a field of 1.5 T to accelerate protons. Consider:
- The RF frequency must be about 22.9 MHz.
- The maximum kinetic energy is about 27 MeV.
- Doubling the field doubles the maximum kinetic energy.
- Deuterons (twice the mass, same charge) in the same machine and field need half the RF frequency and reach half the proton energy.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 only (d) 2 and 3 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
Statement 1: \( f = eB/2\pi m_p = 1.602\times10^{-19}\times1.5/(2\pi\times1.673\times10^{-27}) = 2.29\times10^7 \) Hz. True.
Statement 2: \( K_{\max} = \dfrac{(eBR)^2}{2m_p} = \dfrac{(1.602\times10^{-19}\times0.75)^2}{2\times1.673\times10^{-27}} = 4.32\times10^{-12} \) J \( = 26.9 \) MeV. True (and still small against 938 MeV, so the non-relativistic treatment is fair).
Statement 3: \( K_{\max} \propto B^2 \): doubling \( B \) quadruples it. False.
Statement 4: \( f \propto 1/m \) halves; \( K_{\max} \propto 1/m \) halves. True.
Practice Q7. An electron of kinetic energy 1 keV enters a uniform field of 0.01 T with its velocity at \( 30^\circ \) to the field. The radius and pitch of its helix are closest to:
(a) 5.3 mm and 58 mm (b) 10.7 mm and 58 mm (c) 5.3 mm and 34 mm (d) 9.2 mm and 33 mm
Answer: (a) 5.3 mm and 58 mm
\( v = \sqrt{2K/m_e} = \sqrt{2\times1.602\times10^{-16}/9.109\times10^{-31}} = 1.876\times10^7 \) m/s.
\( r = \dfrac{m_ev\sin30^\circ}{eB} = \dfrac{9.109\times10^{-31}\times9.38\times10^6}{1.602\times10^{-21}} = 5.33\times10^{-3} \) m.
Pitch \( = \dfrac{2\pi m_ev\cos30^\circ}{eB} = \dfrac{2\pi\times9.109\times10^{-31}\times1.624\times10^7}{1.602\times10^{-21}} = 0.058 \) m.
Option (b) uses the full speed for the radius; option (c) swaps sine and cosine in the pitch; option (d) swaps them in both.
Quick Revision Table
| Result | Formula |
|---|---|
| Force | \( d\mathbf p/dt = q(\mathbf E + \mathbf v\times\mathbf B) \); only \( \mathbf E \) does work |
| Uniform \( \mathbf E \) | parabola; screen deflection \( \frac{EL}{2V_a}(\frac{L}{2} + D) \) |
| Relativistic, from rest in \( \mathbf E \) | \( p = qEt \), \( x = \frac{mc^2}{qE}[\sqrt{1 + (qEt/mc)^2} - 1] \) |
| Gyration | \( r = p_\perp/qB \), \( \omega_c = qB/\gamma m \) |
| Helix pitch | \( 2\pi\gamma mv_\parallel/qB \) |
| Practical | \( p\,[\text{GeV}/c] = 0.3B\,[\text{T}]\,r\,[\text{m}] \) |
| \( f_c \) per tesla | electron 28 GHz; proton 15.2 MHz |
| Drift | \( \mathbf v_d = \mathbf E\times\mathbf B/B^2 \) |
| Cycloid | \( y_{\max} = 2mE/qB^2 \); \( v_{\max} = 2E/B \) |
| Cyclotron | \( K_{\max} = q^2B^2R^2/2m \) |
| Mass spectrometer | \( r = \sqrt{2mV/q}/B \) |
| Hall | \( V_H = IB/nqt \) |
| Hamiltonian | \( (\mathbf p - q\mathbf A)^2/2m + qV \); Landau \( (n + \frac{1}{2})\hbar\omega_c \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Electromagnetic Theory: Quick Revision: the whole unit on one page.
- Electromagnetic Theory chapter overview for the syllabus map and the order of topics.
- Magnetostatics and Electromagnetic Induction for the field sources these particles move in.
- Spin and orbital magnetic moments in fields: Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom.