Alpha, Beta and Gamma Decay: Selection Rules
CSIR NET radioactive decay: decay law and equilibrium, alpha tunnelling and Geiger–Nuttall, Fermi beta theory, Fermi/Gamow–Teller rules, gamma multipoles.
- 20 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Nuclear Force, the Deuteron and the Shell Model: the \( J^\pi \) of initial and final states, which every selection rule uses.
- WKB Approximation: the barrier-penetration integral behind alpha decay.
- Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method: Fermi’s golden rule, the starting point of beta-decay theory.
- Nuclear Size, Shape, Spin, Parity and the Liquid Drop Model: mass parabolas and Q-values from binding energies.
The Hook: One Law, Three Very Different Clocks
The Decay Law
Each nucleus has a constant probability per unit time \( \lambda \) of decaying, independent of its age:
$$\frac{dN}{dt} = -\lambda N, \qquad N(t) = N_0e^{-\lambda t}$$| Quantity | Formula |
|---|---|
| Half-life | \( t_{1/2} = \ln2/\lambda \approx 0.693/\lambda \) |
| Mean life | \( \tau = 1/\lambda = t_{1/2}/\ln2 \approx 1.44\,t_{1/2} \) |
| Activity | \( \mathcal{A} = \lambda N \), in becquerel (1 Bq = 1 decay/s); 1 Ci = \( 3.7\times10^{10} \) Bq |
| Several modes | \( \lambda = \sum_i\lambda_i \); branching ratio \( \lambda_i/\lambda \) |
| Energy width | \( \Gamma = \hbar/\tau \) (\( \hbar = 6.58\times10^{-22} \) MeV s) |
Chains: parent → daughter → …
For \( 1 \to 2 \to \) (stable), starting with pure parent:
$$N_2(t) = \frac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2 - \lambda_1}N_1(0)\left(e^{-\lambda_1t} - e^{-\lambda_2t}\right)$$| Case | Long-time behaviour |
|---|---|
| Secular equilibrium, \( \lambda_1 \ll \lambda_2 \) (parent much longer-lived) | \( \lambda_1N_1 = \lambda_2N_2 \): equal activities |
| Transient equilibrium, \( \lambda_1 < \lambda_2 \) but comparable | \( \mathcal{A}_2/\mathcal{A}_1 = \lambda_2/(\lambda_2 - \lambda_1) > 1 \), both decaying with the parent’s half-life |
| No equilibrium, \( \lambda_1 > \lambda_2 \) | parent dies out; daughter then decays with its own half-life |
In secular equilibrium the number ratio is \( N_2/N_1 = \lambda_1/\lambda_2 = t_{1/2,2}/t_{1/2,1} \). That is how the long half-life of a natural parent such as \( ^{238}\text{U} \) can be found from the measured abundance of a short-lived daughter. The chemist’s side of decay series is in Nuclear Stability and Radioactive Decay.
Alpha Decay
$$^{A}_{Z}\text{X} \to {}^{A-4}_{Z-2}\text{Y} + {}^4_2\text{He}$$Energetics
With atomic masses (the electrons balance):
$$Q_\alpha = \left[M(A, Z) - M(A - 4, Z - 2) - M(^4\text{He})\right]c^2$$Momentum conservation for a decay at rest shares \( Q \) between the alpha and the recoiling daughter:
$$\boxed{T_\alpha = Q\frac{A - 4}{A}}, \qquad T_{\text{recoil}} = Q\frac{4}{A}$$So the alpha particles are monoenergetic for each final state (a line spectrum, often with fine structure from decays to excited daughter levels). Alpha decay is energetically possible for most nuclei above \( A \approx 150 \) because of the large binding energy of \( ^4\text{He} \) (28.3 MeV), and becomes common above lead.
Why it is so slow: Gamow tunnelling
The alpha particle is preformed inside the nucleus and hits the Coulomb barrier, whose height at the nuclear surface, \( 2Z'e^2/(4\pi\varepsilon_0R) \) with \( Z' = Z - 2 \), is roughly 25 to 35 MeV for heavy nuclei (depending on the radius used), far above \( Q \approx 4 \) to 9 MeV. It escapes by tunnelling (Gamow; Gurney and Condon, 1928). The decay constant is
$$\lambda = f\,P, \qquad P \approx e^{-2G}, \qquad G = \frac{1}{\hbar}\int_R^b\sqrt{2m\left[V(r) - Q\right]}\,dr$$where \( f \approx v_{\text{in}}/2R \sim 10^{21} \) s\( ^{-1} \) is the rate of assaults on the barrier and \( b \) is the classical turning point where \( V(b) = Q \). For a thick barrier (\( b \gg R \)) the leading term is
$$2G \approx \frac{2\pi\cdot2Z'e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0\hbar v} = 2\pi\cdot2Z'\alpha\frac{c}{v}$$with \( \alpha \approx 1/137 \) and \( v \) the alpha’s speed outside. Since \( v \propto\sqrt{Q} \), \( \ln\lambda \) is linear in \( Z'/\sqrt{Q} \):
$$\boxed{\log_{10}t_{1/2} = a + b\frac{Z'}{\sqrt{Q}}} \qquad\text{(Geiger–Nuttall law)}$$For heavy nuclei a factor of 2 in \( Q \) changes the half-life by roughly 20 orders of magnitude. The integral itself is the WKB transmission coefficient.
Selection rules for alpha decay
The alpha particle has \( J^\pi = 0^+ \), so it carries only orbital angular momentum \( l_\alpha \):
$$\lvert I_i - I_f\rvert \le l_\alpha \le I_i + I_f, \qquad \pi_i\pi_f = (-1)^{l_\alpha}$$- \( 0^+ \to 0^+ \): \( l_\alpha = 0 \) only.
- \( 0^+ \to 1^- \): \( l = 1 \), allowed. \( 0^+ \to 1^+ \): \( l = 1 \) would need a parity change, so forbidden.
- \( 0^+ \to 2^+ \): \( l = 2 \), allowed but slower; each unit of \( l \) adds a centrifugal barrier \( l(l + 1)\hbar^2/2mr^2 \) that reduces the rate.
Beta Decay
| Process | Nucleon level | Q-value with atomic masses |
|---|---|---|
| \( \beta^- \) | \( n \to p + e^- + \bar\nu_e \) | \( \left[M(Z) - M(Z + 1)\right]c^2 \) |
| \( \beta^+ \) | \( p \to n + e^+ + \nu_e \) (only inside nuclei) | \( \left[M(Z) - M(Z - 1) - 2m_e\right]c^2 \) |
| Electron capture (EC) | \( p + e^- \to n + \nu_e \) | \( \left[M(Z) - M(Z - 1)\right]c^2 - B_e \) |
\( B_e \) is the binding energy of the captured electron (usually K-shell). The \( 2m_ec^2 = 1.022 \) MeV in \( \beta^+ \) arises because the daughter atom has one extra electron to shed and a positron is created. If the atomic mass difference is between 0 and 1.022 MeV, only EC is possible.
| Decay | Q (MeV) |
|---|---|
| Free neutron \( n \to p \) | 0.782 |
| Tritium \( ^3\text{H} \to {}^3\text{He} \) | 0.0186 |
| \( ^{14}\text{C} \to {}^{14}\text{N} \) | 0.156 |
| \( ^{11}\text{C} \to {}^{11}\text{B} \) (\( \beta^+ \)) | 0.961 |
The continuous spectrum and the neutrino
Electrons from a given transition have every kinetic energy from 0 up to an endpoint \( T_{\max} \approx Q \) (the daughter’s recoil is tiny). A two-body decay would give a single line, so either energy is not conserved or an unseen third particle shares it. Pauli (1930) proposed the neutrino: neutral, spin 1/2 (needed for angular momentum, since \( A \) is unchanged and the electron alone would change the total by a half-integer), and of very small mass, since the endpoint coincides with \( Q \).
Fermi theory
Fermi (1934) treated beta decay with the golden rule:
$$\lambda = \frac{2\pi}{\hbar}\lvert M_{fi}\rvert^2\rho(E_f)$$For a contact (zero-range) interaction and a massless neutrino, the phase space for an electron of momentum \( p \) and kinetic energy \( T \) gives the allowed spectrum
$$N(p)\,dp \propto F(Z', p)\,p^2(Q - T)^2\,dp$$\( F(Z', p) \) is the Fermi function, which corrects for the Coulomb field of the daughter: it pushes \( \beta^- \) spectra to lower energies (electrons are attracted back) and \( \beta^+ \) spectra to higher energies (positrons are repelled).
Kurie plot. Plotting \( K = \sqrt{N(p)/(p^2F)} \) against \( T \) gives a straight line \( K \propto (Q - T) \) for allowed transitions with a massless neutrino. The intercept on the \( T \) axis is the endpoint. A non-zero neutrino mass would bend the line down near the endpoint; tritium, with its tiny \( Q \), is used for that reason. Forbidden transitions need an extra shape factor to straighten the plot.
Sargent rule. Integrating the spectrum, for \( Q \gg m_ec^2 \) the total rate grows as \( \lambda \propto Q^5 \).
Comparative half-life. The product \( ft_{1/2} \), where \( f(Z', Q) \) is the integrated phase-space (Fermi) integral, removes the trivial energy dependence and measures \( \lvert M\rvert^2 \) directly. Values span many orders of magnitude, so \( \log_{10}ft \) is quoted: roughly 3 to 3.5 for superallowed transitions, about 4 to 7 for ordinary allowed ones, and larger values for forbidden ones (the ranges overlap).
Selection rules for beta decay
The electron and neutrino are both spin 1/2. Their combined spin is \( S = 0 \) (antiparallel: Fermi) or \( S = 1 \) (parallel: Gamow–Teller). Their orbital angular momentum \( l \) relative to the nucleus decides the degree of forbiddenness; each unit of \( l \) costs a factor of roughly \( (pR/\hbar)^2 \sim 10^{-3} \) or less in rate, because the leptons are created inside a small nucleus.
| Type | \( l \) | \( \Delta I = \lvert I_i - I_f\rvert \) | Parity change? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allowed Fermi | 0 | 0 | no |
| Allowed Gamow–Teller | 0 | 0, 1 (but \( 0 \to 0 \) forbidden) | no |
| First forbidden | 1 | 0, 1 (non-unique), 2 (unique) | yes |
| Second forbidden | 2 | 2 (non-unique), 3 (unique) | no |
| \( n \)-th forbidden | \( n \) | up to \( n + 1 \) | \( (-1)^n \) |
The transitions with \( \Delta I = n + 1 \) are called unique \( n \)-th forbidden; their spectra have a characteristic shape.
Classic examples:
| Transition | \( J^\pi \) change | Type |
|---|---|---|
| \( ^{14}\text{O} \to {}^{14}\text{N}^* \) | \( 0^+ \to 0^+ \) | pure Fermi, superallowed (isobaric analogues) |
| \( ^6\text{He} \to {}^6\text{Li} \) | \( 0^+ \to 1^+ \) | pure Gamow–Teller, allowed |
| \( n \to p \) | \( \tfrac12^+ \to \tfrac12^+ \) | mixed Fermi + GT, allowed |
| \( ^{14}\text{C} \to {}^{14}\text{N} \) | \( 0^+ \to 1^+ \) | allowed GT by the rules, but anomalously slow (5730 y): a small matrix element |
Beta decay violates parity; the Wu experiment with \( ^{60}\text{Co} \) and the helicity of the neutrino are on page 6.
Gamma Decay
An excited nucleus usually reaches its ground state by emitting photons. Energies are typically 0.1 to a few MeV; the nucleus recoils with \( E_R = E_\gamma^2/2Mc^2 \) (about 9 eV for a 1 MeV photon from \( A = 60 \)).
Multipolarity and selection rules
A photon carrying angular momentum \( L \) (in units of \( \hbar \)) is an electric (\( EL \)) or magnetic (\( ML \)) multipole:
$$\lvert I_i - I_f\rvert \le L \le I_i + I_f, \qquad L \ge 1$$$$\pi(EL) = (-1)^L, \qquad \pi(ML) = (-1)^{L+1}$$| \( L \) | Electric | Magnetic |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | E1: parity changes | M1: no change |
| 2 | E2: no change | M2: changes |
| 3 | E3: changes | M3: no change |
| 4 | E4: no change | M4: changes |
There are no \( L = 0 \) photons: a real photon is transverse and carries at least one unit of angular momentum. So a \( 0 \to 0 \) transition cannot go by a single gamma ray. It proceeds by internal conversion (E0) or, if the energy exceeds 1.022 MeV, by internal pair creation. (The first excited \( 0^+ \) state of \( ^{16}\text{O} \), at 6.05 MeV, decays by pair emission.)
Rates: which multipole wins
Single-particle (Weisskopf) estimates give \( \lambda(EL) \propto E_\gamma^{2L+1}R^{2L} \). Two consequences matter:
- Lower \( L \) dominates: each extra unit of \( L \) slows the rate by several orders of magnitude, because \( kR \ll 1 \) for nuclear gamma rays.
- Electric beats magnetic at the same \( L \), by roughly one to two orders of magnitude.
So a mixed transition is dominated by the lowest allowed multipole, with one exception: \( M(L) \) and \( E(L + 1) \) can compete, so M1 + E2 mixtures are common (E2 is strongly enhanced in deformed nuclei). The rule for reading a transition:
| \( \Delta I \), parity change | Lowest multipole (plus the competitor) |
|---|---|
| 0 (non-zero \( I \)), no | M1 (+ E2) |
| 0 (non-zero \( I \)), yes | E1 |
| 1, no | M1 (+ E2) |
| 1, yes | E1 |
| 2, no | E2 |
| 2, yes | M2 (+ E3) |
| 3, yes | E3 |
| 4, yes | M4 (+ E5) |
| \( 0 \to 0 \) | no single photon (E0 by conversion or pairs) |
Isomers
When the only available transition has high \( L \) and low energy, the state can live for nanoseconds to years: a nuclear isomer. Isomers cluster just below magic numbers 50, 82 and 126, where high-\( j \) intruder levels (page 2) sit next to low-\( j \) levels of opposite parity: a \( 9/2^+ \) (\( 1g_{9/2} \)) level next to a \( 1/2^- \) (\( 2p_{1/2} \)) level needs an M4 transition. These “islands of isomerism” were early evidence for the shell model.
Internal conversion
The nucleus can instead give the transition energy directly to an atomic electron, which is ejected with \( T_e = E_\gamma - B_e \) (a line spectrum, unlike beta electrons). The conversion coefficient
$$\alpha = \frac{\lambda_e}{\lambda_\gamma}, \qquad \lambda_{\text{total}} = \lambda_\gamma(1 + \alpha)$$is large for high \( Z \), low energy and high multipolarity, which is exactly where isomers live. Conversion leaves a vacancy, so it is followed by X-rays or Auger electrons.
Recoil-free emission (Mössbauer effect)
For a free nucleus the recoil shifts emission and absorption lines apart by \( 2E_R \), far more than the natural linewidth. In a crystal the whole lattice can take up the momentum, and a fraction of transitions are recoil-free. For the 14.4 keV line of \( ^{57}\text{Fe} \) the free-atom recoil is only about 2 meV, but even that exceeds the natural width; in the lattice, resonant absorption is seen and hyperfine shifts can be measured.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Alpha spectrum: lines (two-body) | Beta spectrum: continuous (three-body) | |
| Internal-conversion electrons: lines at \( E_\gamma - B_e \) | Beta electrons: continuum up to \( Q \) | |
| \( \beta^+ \) threshold: atomic mass difference > \( 2m_ec^2 \) | EC: any positive mass difference (> \( B_e \)) | |
| Secular equilibrium: equal activities | Equal numbers (wrong) | |
| Fermi transition (\( S = 0 \)) | Gamow–Teller (\( S = 1 \)) | |
| \( ML \) parity \( (-1)^{L+1} \) | \( EL \) parity \( (-1)^L \) | |
| Isomer: long-lived excited state of the same nuclide | Isobar: same \( A \), different \( Z \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Use 1 u = 931.494 MeV/\( c^2 \).
Level 1: Foundation
- Can a \( 0^+ \to 0^+ \) nuclear transition proceed by single-photon emission?
- What are \( \Delta I \) and the parity change for an allowed Fermi beta transition?
- What fraction of \( Q_\alpha \) does the alpha particle carry?
Answers
- No. Photons carry \( L \ge 1 \); it goes by internal conversion or pair emission.
- \( \Delta I = 0 \), no parity change.
- \( (A - 4)/A \) of \( Q \), \( A \) being the parent mass number.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Atomic masses: \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \) 226.025410 u, \( ^{222}\text{Rn} \) 222.017578 u, \( ^4\text{He} \) 4.002603 u. The kinetic energy of the alpha particle from \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \) decaying at rest to the ground state of \( ^{222}\text{Rn} \) is closest to:
(a) 4.70 MeV (b) 4.78 MeV (c) 4.87 MeV (d) 5.31 MeV
Answer: (b) 4.78 MeV
\( Q = 0.005229\times931.494 = 4.871 \) MeV; \( T_\alpha = 4.871\times222/226 = 4.784 \) MeV. Option (c) is \( Q \) itself.
Practice Q2. A gamma transition connects a \( 5/2^+ \) state to a \( 1/2^+ \) ground state. Its lowest (dominant) multipolarity is:
(a) E1 (b) M1 (c) E2 (d) M2
Answer: (c) E2
\( L \ge \lvert5/2 - 1/2\rvert = 2 \); no parity change, so \( L = 2 \) must be electric. M3 is also allowed but much slower.
Practice Q3. The beta decay \( ^6\text{He}\,(0^+) \to {}^6\text{Li}\,(1^+) \) is:
(a) allowed, pure Fermi (b) allowed, pure Gamow–Teller (c) first forbidden (d) second forbidden unique
Answer: (b)
No parity change and \( \Delta I = 1 \): allowed, and only the \( S = 1 \) (Gamow–Teller) lepton state can carry the unit of angular momentum. A Fermi transition needs \( \Delta I = 0 \).
Practice Q4. The half-life of \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \) is 1600 years. The activity of 1.00 g of pure \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \) is closest to (take 1 y = \( 3.156\times10^7 \) s):
(a) \( 3.7\times10^8 \) Bq (b) \( 3.7\times10^{10} \) Bq (c) \( 3.7\times10^{12} \) Bq (d) \( 2.7\times10^{21} \) Bq
Answer: (b)
\( \lambda = 0.693/(1600\times3.156\times10^7) = 1.37\times10^{-11} \) s\( ^{-1} \); \( N = 6.022\times10^{23}/226 = 2.66\times10^{21} \); \( \mathcal{A} = 3.66\times10^{10} \) Bq, about 1 Ci, which is how the curie was originally sized. Option (d) is \( N \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Kurie-plot values \( K \) (arbitrary units) for a beta spectrum, corrected with the Fermi function, are given against electron kinetic energy \( T \):
| \( T \) (MeV) | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( K \) | 8.0 | 6.0 | 4.0 |
Consider:
- The endpoint energy is 1.0 MeV.
- A straight Kurie plot is consistent with an allowed transition and a massless neutrino.
- If the decay is \( \beta^+ \), the atomic mass difference between parent and daughter is about 2.02 MeV/\( c^2 \).
- If the decay is \( \beta^+ \), the atomic mass difference is about 1.51 MeV/\( c^2 \).
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 2 and 3 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( K \) falls by 2.0 per 0.2 MeV, so \( K = 10(1.0 - T) \): intercept at \( T = 1.0 \) MeV. Statement 1 true. Statement 2 is the meaning of a straight Kurie plot. True. For \( \beta^+ \), \( Q = \Delta Mc^2 - 2m_ec^2 \), so \( \Delta Mc^2 = 1.0 + 1.022 = 2.02 \) MeV. Statement 3 true, statement 4 false (it adds only one electron mass).
Practice Q6. A nucleus has a \( 1/2^- \) ground state and a \( 9/2^+ \) excited state 0.10 MeV above it, with no levels in between. Consider:
- The lowest allowed multipolarity of the \( 9/2^+ \to 1/2^- \) transition is M4.
- The \( 9/2^+ \) state is expected to be long-lived (an isomer).
- Its internal-conversion coefficient is expected to be large.
- The transition can proceed by E1 emission.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( L \ge 4 \); parity changes, and for \( L = 4 \) only the magnetic multipole changes parity: M4 (with E5 as the competitor). Statement 1 true; statement 4 false since \( L = 1 \) cannot connect \( \Delta I = 4 \). High \( L \) and low energy give a tiny photon rate: an isomer. Statement 2 true. Conversion grows with \( L \) and as \( E \) falls. Statement 3 true. This \( g_{9/2} \)–\( p_{1/2} \) pair is the classic isomer just below 50.
Practice Q7. \( ^{226}\text{Ra} \) (\( t_{1/2} = 1600 \) y) decays to \( ^{222}\text{Rn} \) (\( t_{1/2} = 3.82 \) d). A sealed sample initially containing 1.00 g of pure radium is left for several months. Consider:
- Radon reaches secular equilibrium with radium after about a month.
- In equilibrium, the radon activity equals the radium activity.
- In equilibrium, the number of radon atoms is about \( 6.5\times10^{-6} \) of the number of radium atoms.
- The equilibrium mass of radon is about 6.4 mg.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
1: After about 8 radon half-lives (31 days) the factor \( 1 - e^{-\lambda_2t} \) exceeds 0.99. True. 2: Secular equilibrium is \( \lambda_1N_1 = \lambda_2N_2 \). True. 3: \( N_2/N_1 = 3.82/(1600\times365.25) = 6.54\times10^{-6} \). True. 4: Mass ratio \( 6.54\times10^{-6}\times222/226 = 6.43\times10^{-6} \), so about 6.4 μg, not mg. False.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Result |
|---|---|
| Decay law | \( N = N_0e^{-\lambda t} \), \( t_{1/2} = 0.693/\lambda \), \( \tau = 1/\lambda \), \( \Gamma = \hbar/\tau \) |
| Secular equilibrium | \( \lambda_1N_1 = \lambda_2N_2 \) |
| Alpha energy | \( T_\alpha = Q(A - 4)/A \) |
| Gamow | \( \lambda = fe^{-2G} \), \( 2G \approx 2\pi\cdot2Z'\alpha c/v \) |
| Geiger–Nuttall | \( \log t_{1/2} = a + bZ'/\sqrt{Q} \) |
| Alpha rule | \( \pi_i\pi_f = (-1)^{l_\alpha} \) |
| \( \beta^- \), \( \beta^+ \), EC (atomic masses) | \( \Delta M \); \( \Delta M - 2m_e \); \( \Delta M - B_e/c^2 \) |
| Allowed spectrum | \( N(p) \propto Fp^2(Q - T)^2 \); Kurie plot straight |
| Sargent | \( \lambda \propto Q^5 \) |
| Fermi / GT | \( \Delta I = 0 \) / \( 0, \pm1 \) (no \( 0 \to 0 \)); no parity change |
| First forbidden | \( \Delta I = 0, 1, 2 \), parity changes |
| Gamma | \( L \ge 1 \); \( EL \): \( (-1)^L \); \( ML \): \( (-1)^{L+1} \) |
| Conversion | \( \alpha = \lambda_e/\lambda_\gamma \), large for high \( Z \), low \( E \), high \( L \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Nuclear Reactions, Fission and Fusion: Q-values and conservation laws for collisions instead of spontaneous decays.
- C, P, T Invariance and Relativistic Kinematics: beta decay is where parity violation was discovered.
- Nuclear and Particle Physics overview.
- From the chemistry syllabus: Radio-analytical Techniques, where these decays are used for measurement.