Identical Particles, Pauli Principle and Spin-Statistics
CSIR NET quantum mechanics: exchange symmetry, bosons and fermions, Slater determinants, singlet and triplet states, helium, state counting, practice.
- 16 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why Atoms Have Size
- Exchange Symmetry
- The Spin-Statistics Connection
- Two-Particle States
- Spin and Space Together
- Exchange “Forces”
- Counting States
- Filling Levels: Ground States of Many Particles
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom: singlet and triplet states of two spin-1/2 particles.
- One-Dimensional Problems: Box, Oscillator and Tunnelling: the single-particle levels we will fill.
- Selections and arrangements from Counting, Probability and Number Properties: state counting below is exactly that combinatorics.
The Hook: Why Atoms Have Size
Exchange Symmetry
Classical particles can be labelled and tracked. Quantum particles of the same species cannot: their wave packets overlap and there is no trajectory to follow. Define the exchange operator \( \hat P_{12} \) by
$$\hat P_{12}\,\psi(1, 2) = \psi(2, 1)$$where “1” stands for all coordinates (position and spin) of particle 1. For identical particles \( [\hat P_{12},\hat H] = 0 \), and since \( \hat P_{12}^2 = 1 \) its eigenvalues are \( \pm1 \).
The symmetrisation postulate goes further: the state of identical particles must be an eigenstate of every exchange, with the same sign for all pairs:
- Bosons: symmetric, \( \psi(1, 2) = +\psi(2, 1) \).
- Fermions: antisymmetric, \( \psi(1, 2) = -\psi(2, 1) \).
The Spin-Statistics Connection
$$\boxed{\text{integer spin} \Rightarrow \text{bosons (symmetric)}, \qquad \text{half-integer spin} \Rightarrow \text{fermions (antisymmetric)}}$$In non-relativistic quantum mechanics this is a postulate. It is a theorem of relativistic quantum field theory (Pauli, 1940). Examples:
| Particle | Spin | Statistics |
|---|---|---|
| electron, proton, neutron, neutrino, quarks | 1/2 | fermion |
| photon | 1 | boson |
| pion | 0 | boson |
| deuteron (p + n) | 1 | boson |
For a composite particle, count its fermion constituents: an odd number makes it a fermion, an even number a boson (provided the internal state is not disturbed by the exchange). Helium-4 (2 protons, 2 neutrons, 2 electrons: six fermions) is a boson; helium-3 (five fermions) is a fermion. That difference is why \( ^4 \)He becomes superfluid at about 2.17 K while \( ^3 \)He needs temperatures in the millikelvin range, where its atoms pair up.
Two-Particle States
Take two non-interacting particles, one in single-particle state \( \psi_a \) and one in \( \psi_b \).
$$\text{Distinguishable: } \psi_a(x_1)\psi_b(x_2)$$$$\boxed{\psi_\pm(x_1, x_2) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[\psi_a(x_1)\psi_b(x_2) \pm \psi_b(x_1)\psi_a(x_2)\right]}$$with \( + \) for bosons and \( - \) for fermions (\( a \neq b \)). If \( a = b \), the boson state is simply \( \psi_a(x_1)\psi_a(x_2) \), and the fermion state vanishes identically:
$$\boxed{\text{Pauli exclusion principle: two identical fermions cannot occupy the same single-particle state.}}$$For \( N \) fermions in states \( a, b, c, \ldots \), the antisymmetric state is the Slater determinant
$$\psi = \frac{1}{\sqrt{N!}}\begin{vmatrix}\psi_a(1) & \psi_b(1) & \cdots\\ \psi_a(2) & \psi_b(2) & \cdots\\ \vdots & \vdots & \ddots\end{vmatrix}$$which vanishes whenever two columns (states) or two rows (particles at the same point with the same spin) coincide.
Spin and Space Together
For electrons the “state” includes spin, so the antisymmetry applies to the full product of spatial and spin parts. For two electrons, with spin states from Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom:
| Spatial part | Spin part | Total spin | Count |
|---|---|---|---|
| symmetric \( \psi_+ \) | singlet (antisymmetric) | \( S = 0 \) | 1 |
| antisymmetric \( \psi_- \) | triplet (symmetric) | \( S = 1 \) | 3 |
Two electrons in the same orbital must therefore be in the spin singlet: “paired” spins. Two electrons in different orbitals can be in either combination, giving four states in all.
For two identical bosons of spin \( s \), the total must be symmetric. For two spin-1 bosons the coupled states \( S = 2 \) and \( S = 0 \) are symmetric and \( S = 1 \) is antisymmetric (in general, \( S = 2s, 2s - 2, \ldots \) are symmetric). So two spin-1 bosons in the same orbital can only have \( S = 2 \) or \( S = 0 \).
Exchange “Forces”
Symmetry alone, with no interaction, changes how close identical particles tend to be. For two particles in states \( a \) and \( b \) in one dimension,
$$\boxed{\langle(x_1 - x_2)^2\rangle_\pm = \langle x^2\rangle_a + \langle x^2\rangle_b - 2\langle x\rangle_a\langle x\rangle_b \mp 2\left\lvert\langle x\rangle_{ab}\right\rvert^2}$$where \( \langle x\rangle_{ab} = \int x\,\psi_a^*(x)\psi_b(x)\,dx \). The first three terms are the distinguishable-particle result. Symmetric spatial states (upper sign) pull the particles together; antisymmetric ones push them apart. The correction exists only when the wavefunctions overlap, so electrons in different atoms far apart can be treated as distinguishable.
This “exchange force” is not a new interaction; it is a consequence of symmetry. Combined with the Coulomb repulsion it has big effects:
- Helium excited states. In the \( 1s\,2s \) configuration, the triplet (orthohelium, spatially antisymmetric) keeps the electrons apart, so their repulsion is smaller and it lies below the singlet (parahelium). With direct integral \( J \) and exchange integral \( K > 0 \), the energies are \( E_0 + J \mp K \) (triplet with the minus sign). The helium ground state \( 1s^2 \) is necessarily a singlet.
- Hund’s first rule. In atoms, the term of maximum spin multiplicity in a configuration usually lies lowest, for the same reason.
- Chemical bond. In H\( _2 \) the bonding orbital is spatially symmetric, so the bound ground state is a spin singlet.
- Ferromagnetism. Exchange favours parallel spins in iron, cobalt and nickel.
Because electric-dipole transitions do not act on spin (\( \Delta S = 0 \)), singlet and triplet helium hardly connect radiatively. Their two separate spectra are why the singlet and triplet systems were given different names, parahelium and orthohelium.
Nuclear spin and molecular rotation
The same logic applies to nuclei. In H\( _2 \) the two protons are fermions. Exchanging them reverses the internuclear axis, which multiplies the rotational wavefunction by \( (-1)^J \) (the electronic and vibrational ground states are symmetric). So:
- para-hydrogen: nuclear spin singlet (\( I = 0 \), antisymmetric) with even \( J \);
- ortho-hydrogen: nuclear spin triplet (\( I = 1 \), symmetric) with odd \( J \).
At high temperature the ortho : para ratio tends to the spin-degeneracy ratio 3 : 1, which shows up as alternating line intensities in the rotational Raman spectrum.
Counting States
For \( N \) particles distributed over \( g \) single-particle states (each state labelled by orbital and spin):
| Particles | Number of states |
|---|---|
| distinguishable | \( g^N \) |
| identical bosons | \( \binom{N + g - 1}{N} \) |
| identical fermions | \( \binom{g}{N} \) (zero if \( N > g \)) |
For two particles in two states: 4 (distinguishable), 3 (bosons), 1 (fermions). Distinguishable particles are found in the same state half the time; bosons two-thirds of the time; fermions never. This is the microscopic origin of Maxwell–Boltzmann, Bose–Einstein and Fermi–Dirac statistics, developed in the thermodynamics and statistical physics unit listed on the Physical Sciences overview.
Filling Levels: Ground States of Many Particles
For non-interacting particles, the many-body ground state fills single-particle levels from the bottom:
- Bosons: all \( N \) in the lowest level.
- Spin-1/2 fermions: two per spatial level (spin up and down).
- Spinless (or spin-polarised) fermions: one per level.
In a 1D infinite well with levels \( E_n = n^2E_1 \):
| \( N \) | Spinless bosons | Spin-1/2 fermions | Spinless fermions |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | \( 2E_1 \) | \( 2E_1 \) | \( 5E_1 \) |
| 3 | \( 3E_1 \) | \( 6E_1 \) | \( 14E_1 \) |
| 4 | \( 4E_1 \) | \( 10E_1 \) | \( 30E_1 \) |
In a 1D oscillator, \( N \) spin-1/2 fermions fill \( n = 0, 0, 1, 1, 2, 2, \ldots \). With \( N \) even, the highest filled level is \( n_F = N/2 - 1 \).
The highest occupied energy is the Fermi energy. For \( N \) (even) spin-1/2 fermions in a 1D box, \( E_F = (N/2)^2E_1 \). For a 3D free-electron gas of number density \( n \),
$$E_F = \frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(3\pi^2n\right)^{2/3}$$and the mean energy per particle at zero temperature is \( \frac{3}{5}E_F \). This zero-point “degeneracy pressure” holds up white dwarfs and makes the electron heat capacity of metals small.
The ground-state degeneracy depends on whether the last level is full. With an odd number of spin-1/2 fermions, the unpaired one can be up or down: degeneracy 2.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Pauli principle: no two fermions in the same single-particle state (orbital and spin) | two electrons can share an orbital with opposite spins | |
| Triplet: symmetric spin, antisymmetric space | Singlet: antisymmetric spin, symmetric space | |
| Exchange force: from symmetry, no interaction | Coulomb repulsion: a real interaction (exchange changes its average) | |
| Orthohelium: triplet, lower in the same configuration | Parahelium: singlet, includes the ground state | |
| para-H\( _2 \): nuclear singlet, even \( J \) | ortho-H\( _2 \): nuclear triplet, odd \( J \) | |
| \( \binom{g}{N} \) for fermions | \( \binom{N+g-1}{N} \) for bosons |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. \( E_1 \) denotes the ground-state energy of a single particle in the given 1D infinite well.
Level 1: Foundation
- Is the two-electron spin singlet symmetric or antisymmetric under exchange?
- Is a \( ^4 \)He atom a boson or a fermion?
- In how many ways can two identical bosons occupy three single-particle states?
Answers
- Antisymmetric. \( \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\lvert\uparrow\downarrow\rangle - \lvert\downarrow\uparrow\rangle) \) changes sign.
- Boson. Six fermion constituents (2 p, 2 n, 2 e), an even number.
- 6. \( \binom{2 + 3 - 1}{2} = \binom{4}{2} = 6 \): three doubly occupied plus three with the bosons in different states.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Three non-interacting electrons are placed in a one-dimensional infinite well. The ground-state energy of the system is:
(a) \( 3E_1 \) (b) \( 6E_1 \) (c) \( 9E_1 \) (d) \( 14E_1 \)
Answer: (b) 6E₁
Two electrons (opposite spins) in \( n = 1 \), one in \( n = 2 \): \( 2E_1 + 4E_1 = 6E_1 \). (a) treats them as bosons; (d) ignores spin.
Practice Q2. Two non-interacting spin-1/2 fermions are in a one-dimensional harmonic oscillator. The energy and degeneracy of the first excited level of the system are:
(a) \( 2\hbar\omega \), 4 (b) \( 2\hbar\omega \), 3 (c) \( 2\hbar\omega \), 1 (d) \( 3\hbar\omega \), 4
Answer: (a) 2ħω, 4
Ground state: both in \( n = 0 \), singlet, energy \( \hbar\omega \). First excited: one in \( n = 0 \), one in \( n = 1 \), energy \( \frac{1}{2}\hbar\omega + \frac{3}{2}\hbar\omega = 2\hbar\omega \). Since the orbitals differ, both the symmetric-space singlet (1 state) and antisymmetric-space triplet (3 states) are allowed: degeneracy 4.
Practice Q3. Two identical spin-1/2 fermions can each occupy any of three orthonormal spatial orbitals. The number of allowed two-particle states is:
(a) 9 (b) 12 (c) 15 (d) 36
Answer: (c) 15
Six single-particle states; \( \binom{6}{2} = 15 \). (b) forgets the three doubly occupied orbitals (singlet only); (d) is \( 6^2 \), the distinguishable count.
Practice Q4. Two identical particles occupy the states \( \psi_1 \) and \( \psi_2 \) of an infinite well \( 0 < x < L \), in the antisymmetric spatial combination in one case and the symmetric one in the other. Given \( \langle x\rangle_{12} = -\frac{16L}{9\pi^2} \), by how much does \( \langle(x_1 - x_2)^2\rangle \) in the antisymmetric case exceed that in the symmetric case?
(a) \( 0.032L^2 \) (b) \( 0.065L^2 \) (c) \( 0.130L^2 \) (d) 0
Answer: (c) 0.130 L²
The difference is \( 2\lvert\langle x\rangle_{12}\rvert^2 - (-2\lvert\langle x\rangle_{12}\rvert^2) = 4\lvert\langle x\rangle_{12}\rvert^2 = 4\left(\frac{16}{9\pi^2}\right)^2L^2 = \frac{1024}{81\pi^4}L^2 \approx 0.130L^2 \).
(b) is the shift of one case from the distinguishable value, not the gap between the two cases.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Five non-interacting spin-1/2 fermions are placed in a one-dimensional harmonic oscillator of frequency \( \omega \). Consider:
- The ground-state energy is \( \frac{13}{2}\hbar\omega \).
- The ground state is non-degenerate.
- If the particles were spinless bosons, the ground-state energy would be \( \frac{5}{2}\hbar\omega \).
- If the fermions were spin-polarised (all spin up), the ground-state energy would be \( \frac{25}{2}\hbar\omega \).
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 3 and 4 only
- Fill \( n = 0, 0, 1, 1, 2 \): \( 2\times\frac{1}{2} + 2\times\frac{3}{2} + \frac{5}{2} = 1 + 3 + 2.5 = 6.5\hbar\omega = \frac{13}{2}\hbar\omega \). True.
- The fifth fermion, alone in \( n = 2 \), can be up or down: degeneracy 2. False.
- All five in \( n = 0 \): \( \frac{5}{2}\hbar\omega \). True.
- One per level, \( n = 0 \) to \( 4 \): \( \sum_{n=0}^{4}(n + \frac{1}{2}) = 10 + \frac{5}{2} = \frac{25}{2}\hbar\omega \). True.
Practice Q6. Consider the excited configuration \( 1s\,2s \) of helium, including the electron–electron repulsion to first order. Consider:
- The spin-triplet states have an antisymmetric spatial wavefunction.
- The triplet lies below the singlet, because the electrons are kept further apart.
- Electric-dipole transitions connect the \( 1s\,2s \) triplet to the \( 1s^2 \) ground state.
- The ground state \( 1s^2 \) can be a spin triplet.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1 and 3 only
Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only
- Total antisymmetry with a symmetric triplet spin part requires antisymmetric space. True.
- The antisymmetric spatial state vanishes at \( \mathbf r_1 = \mathbf r_2 \), lowering the mean repulsion by the exchange integral: \( E = E_0 + J - K \) versus \( E_0 + J + K \). True.
- \( 1s^2 \) is a singlet, and dipole transitions conserve \( S \); also \( 2s \to 1s \) has \( \Delta l = 0 \). False on both counts.
- Both electrons in 1s means a symmetric spatial part, so the spin part must be the singlet. False.
Practice Q7. Two identical spin-1 bosons are non-interacting. Consider:
- If both are in the same spatial orbital, the allowed total spin values are \( S = 0 \) and \( S = 2 \) only.
- If both are in the same spatial orbital, there are 6 allowed states.
- If they are in two different orbitals, there are 9 allowed states.
- If they are in two different orbitals, \( S = 1 \) is forbidden.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
For two spin-1 particles, \( S = 2 \) (5 states) and \( S = 0 \) (1 state) are symmetric; \( S = 1 \) (3 states) is antisymmetric.
1 and 2. Same orbital: symmetric space, so symmetric spin: \( S = 2 \) or 0, \( 5 + 1 = 6 \) states. Check: \( \binom{3 + 2 - 1}{2} = 6 \). True.
Different orbitals: symmetric space with \( S = 2, 0 \) (6 states) plus antisymmetric space with \( S = 1 \) (3 states): 9. Check: three spin states for each particle, one particle per orbital, \( 3\times3 = 9 \). True.
\( S = 1 \) is allowed with the antisymmetric spatial combination. False.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Exchange | \( \hat P_{12} \) eigenvalues \( \pm1 \) |
| Spin-statistics | integer spin: bosons; half-integer: fermions |
| Composite | odd number of fermions: fermion |
| Two-particle state | \( \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[\psi_a\psi_b \pm \psi_b\psi_a] \) |
| Pauli | fermion state vanishes if \( a = b \) |
| Two electrons | symmetric space with singlet; antisymmetric space with triplet |
| Exchange effect | \( \mp2\lvert\langle x\rangle_{ab}\rvert^2 \) in \( \langle(x_1 - x_2)^2\rangle \) |
| Helium \( 1s2s \) | triplet (ortho) below singlet (para) |
| H\( _2 \) | para: \( I = 0 \), even \( J \); ortho: \( I = 1 \), odd \( J \); 3 : 1 at high \( T \) |
| Counting | fermions \( \binom{g}{N} \), bosons \( \binom{N+g-1}{N} \) |
| 3 electrons in a box | \( 6E_1 \) |
| 3D Fermi energy | \( \frac{\hbar^2}{2m}(3\pi^2n)^{2/3} \); mean \( \frac{3}{5}E_F \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Quantum Mechanics: Quick Revision: the whole chapter on one page.
- Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method: revisit helium’s ground state with the symmetry rules from this page.
- Quantum Mechanics (Core) overview: the learning path and how the paper asks this unit.
- Electron configurations, Hund’s rules and spin multiplicity in Chemical Sciences.